NFL To Review Catch Rule That Gave Bears Victory

CHICAGO — The NFL expects to review the catch rule that cost Lions receiver Calvin Johnson a potential winning touchdown in a season-opening loss to Chicago.

The play was ruled a no-catch. After Johnson went to the turf with possession, he placed the ball on the ground as he ran to celebrate. It’s been one of the season’s most discussed — and dissed — calls.

“The going-to-the-ground rule definitely will be discussed,” NFL competition committee co-chairman Rich McKay said Tuesday at the league’s fall meetings. “It’s been discussed the last couple of years. It’s a difficult rule. It was made for on-field officials, not as much for people watching on TV.

“There’s a definite conflict. We have to go back and look if we extended it too far.”

The competition committee will meet after the Super Bowl and then suggest any rules changes to team owners at the league’s spring meetings in March.

Against Chicago, with Detroit trailing 19-14, Johnson leaped to grab a pass from Shaun Hill in the end zone. He got both feet and a knee on the ground before putting the ball on the grass and beginning to celebrate. It was ruled incomplete because Johnson didn’t maintain possession of the ball throughout the entire process of the catch.

McKay also said another move that drew criticism, switching the umpire from behind the defense line to behind the offensive backfield, is working. He hasn’t seen any video of an umpire being hit by another player; last season, there were “between 105 and 115 hits on video.”

But the move has affected the number of offensive holding penalties, which were up through four weeks. Placing the umpire behind the offense apparently has given him a better view of blocking on the line.

Several quarterbacks, particularly Peyton Manning, complained in the preseason that the new positioning of the umpires delayed spotting of the ball to restart play.

“That has not been an issue like some thought it would be in the preseason,” said McKay, the president of the Atlanta Falcons.

One trend the league is concerned with is the number of helmets that have flown off players’ heads. McKay informally charts such things and the league office is keeping count.

“We’re going back to the each manufacturer and asking why it’s happening,” he said. “It’s definitely something we should be looking at. The union … and everyone is in on this issue.”

The union definitely is not in on the league’s claim it needs a better collective bargaining agreement. The owners opted out of the CBA in 2008 and it expires in March.

These meetings are expected to include discussions of the owners’ plans for labor negotiations and any contingency plans if there is a lockout next year. So far, there have been few serious negotiating sessions.

“It’s taken a lot of time and energy to build the league into what it is and we want to keep it going,” Colts owner Jimmy Irsay said Tuesday. “I don’t think it’s doomsday, and we’re taking it a day at a time. Everybody is engaged and from my perspective, the key thing is to find a solution and that’s where both sides are. I know that energy (to reach a deal) will be there.”

Commissioner Roger Goodell and the NFL Alumni announced a partnership to benefit retired players that will include the Gay Culverhouse Players’ Outreach Program.

Efforts will include hiring case workers, establishment of a toll-free hotline and personal contact with retired players and their families through events sponsored by NFL Alumni and the Culverhouse program.

“There are very comprehensive benefits and services available,” Goodell said. “But too often former players and their families don’t know what they are or how to gain access to the programs.”

Copyright 2010 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.

  • Bobbi70

    This rule needs to be changed NOW. This ball was caught!! Many players break the plane and lose the ball and it is still ruled a touchdown. The decision should be reversed, giving the Lions the win. What’s fair is fair. He had possession. PERIOD.

    • Mark, Sterling

      Sounds like some sour grapes there. The ball may have been caught and I do agree that it kinda sucks for Lions fans and Calvin Johnson…but that IS the rule. And please stop comparing CATCHING the ball in the end zone to RUNNING it into the end zone. They are ENTIRELY different. A player who runs it in already HAS possession established BEFORE they reach the end zone which is why they can drop it right away. A receiver has to ESTABLISH POSSESSION! Which is the whole reason this rule was put in to begin with.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live