Spiegel: Perhaps The Worst Cubs Idea Of All Time

The Ryne Sandberg as bench coach idea, under Mike Quade as manager, would be the dumbest in an impressive line of bad Cubs maneuvers.  Will Carroll of reported this as a possibility from a source.

If the Cubs do this, they are courting a split locker room, inviting media derision, and begging for a fan uprising at the hint of a losing streak.

If you wanted Ryno as part of your team, why didn’t you just do it during the season when you had so many chances to do so?  I was a proponent of making him Lou Piniella’s bench coach for the second half of the year, which would have eliminated the only knock people have on him: big league experience.  Lou might have gone for it too, making a graceful exit while helping to train the darling of the franchise.

There’s no way Will Carroll’s report is true.  It can’t possibly be true.

Will Carroll On The Laurence Holmes Show

My Hit and Run partner Barry Rozner wrote it in the Herald yesterday.  The time to name someone was the last 2 days…right now.  You’re between MLB playoff series, and before Jim Hendry’s desired October 15th timetable.

But they didn’t…Tom Ricketts wants to wait for November 15th, remember?  That means offering it to Joe Girardi.

I still think there’s no way Girardi comes.  No chance.  His agent is working to spread the opposite amongst baseball people, but I still contend that’s only to use the Cubs for what they ought to be renamed:  The Chicago Leverage.  Girardi will get an enormous deal to stay with the Yankees.

Jim Hendry doesn’t want Joe Girardi.  He didn’t want him last time.  Girardi had to beg for an interview last time…when they hired Lou.  Think about that…he had to work to get an interview.  And the man who didn’t want you then, is still surprisingly in charge, despite his many failings.

If you’re Girardi…you want to come here?  Really?  With a bad roster  full of dead money veterans and over-hyped youngsters?  With all due respect to Byrd, Dempster, Marmol, Marshall, Castro, Colvin, and Cashner,  you really want to coach the rest of that lot?  You want to come here to work for a GM that didn’t want you in the first place, who also appears to be pretty bad at his job?  You want to come here to work for an ownership that is entrusting the baseball operations to the aforementioned bad GM,  who again doesn’t want you in the first place?  You want to leave the Yankees for this?

This job will be there for Girardi again down the road.  Perhaps one day it’ll be there with a clean slate, coupled with a GM who he wants to work with and believes in.

Until then…give it to Quade.  Or give it to Sandberg.  Let them choose a bench coach, an old baseball salt to sit with and kick things around.  Hell, it’ll be the only coach they get to choose anyway.

More from Matt Spiegel
  • michael

    I say put Ryne in there , next year will be a getting used to the Cubs year for any manager so why not Ryne? the Angels that are playing behind the Bears will come over to Wrigley for next season and that I am positive of, why? just beleive me… Yowza!!

  • Rumor: Quade As Manager And Sandberg As Bench Coach « CBS Chicago – News, Sports, Weather, Traffic, and the Best of Chicago

    […] more on Quade, Sandberg and the Cubs’ managerial position read the most recent Matt Spiegel and David Schuster […]

  • Lydell

    All time? What about investing $30mil in Cousin Miltie over Raul Ibanez, Bobby Abreu or even Ronnie Woowoo?

  • merklesboner

    College of Coaches was pretty dumb too, P.K. Wrigley (R.I.P.)

  • Johnny Fontane

    If you take two contenders for the job and make one manager an one bench coach, won’t one always be looking over his shoulder? That’s a bad idea no matter who the guys are. You find the best guy for the job and give it to him. Period.

  • Mathew Idicula

    For sure one of the sappies decisions they have made in quite some time and like this year, I am sure the cubs can cancel their post season hopes by early July.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live