Controversy Erupts Over East Lakeview Wal-Mart Plan

UPDATED 12/10/10 11:53 a.m.

CHICAGO (CBS) — Controversy has already erupted about plans for a Wal-Mart store in the East Lakeview neighborhood, within 24 hours of reports of the planned store.

Quoting “real estate sources,” Crain’s Chicago Real Estate Daily reported Thursday that Wal-Mart hopes to lease 30,000 square feet in the Broadway at Surf complex, at 2840 N. Broadway.

Also quoting real estate sources, the Chicago Sun-Times reported Friday morning that the deal was in the final stages. But Wal-Mart director of community affairs Steve Restivo would not confirm or deny interest in the space, the Sun-Times reported.

The Wal-Mart would be a Neighborhood Market store, focusing on groceries and a limited general merchandise selection, reports said. It would take over a three-story, 30,000 square-foot space formerly occupied by a PetSmart in the Broadway at Surf complex, which is currently anchored by a Bed, Bath and Beyond, a T.J. Maxx and a Cost Plus World Market.

Within a day, some neighborhood residents were protesting the idea. Lakeview activist Bruce Beal started a Facebook group, “Stop the Lakeview/Lincoln Park Wal-Mart,” which had nearly 400 members as of midday Friday.

One member of the group, Jason Pike, posted a letter to Ald. Tom Tunney (44th), which said diverse small businesses are “at the heart of what makes our home special in the city of Chicago,” and a big-box store would threaten those businesses. Pike also slammed Wal-Mart for its corporate policies, wages, and stance on workers organizing.

“Livelihoods are at stake, the beauty and diversity of one of Chicago’s most unique communities is at stake, and Lakeview’s small business owners are entitled to better from their city government,” Pike wrote. “The cost of WalMart’s low prices is just too high for our community.”

On Thursday, Beal told WBBM Newsradio 780’s Mike Krauser: “There is no support among any constituency in this area for this idea. It’s just a really bad site for this kind of a development. Set aside all of the problems with Wal-Mart. The intersection of Diversey, Clark and Broadway is a D-minus-rated intersection that is just a horrific traffic and population management problem.”

Beal also pointed out that there are already two grocery stores within a block-and-a-half, so the neighborhood isn’t in need of another grocery.

The Lakeview East Chamber of Commerce has endorsed Beal’s efforts, urging neighbors to “keep small business in our community.”

Tunney said in a statement on his website that he has not seen any conceptual plans for a Wal-Mart in the Broadway at Surf, but if plans are released, they will be “vetted through a rigorous community process.”

“As a small business owner, I understand the impact any big-box retailer would have on our neighborhood,” Tunney said in the statement. “We will work together, residents and businesses, to continue to make our community a better place to live, raise a family, shop and own a business.”

In addition to the three anchor stores, the Broadway at Surf also houses a Sprint store and a Palm Beach Tan salon. But it has seen several vacancies in recent years. In addition to the former PetSmart, a Wolf Camera store, a Hollywood Video store, and the Maui Wowi Hawaiian coffee and smoothie café, all sit vacant.

The complex takes up nearly a full block on the west side of Broadway, between Surf Street and the alley next to the Borders bookstore just north of Diversey. It opened in 1997 after developers razed all the buildings on the once-seedy block.

At one time, the block included the Times Square video arcade, the Broadway Girlies adult bookstore and peep show, Shanghai Minnie’s Chinese restaurant, Brian Boru’s tavern, and a nightclub that was known variously over the years as the Paradise disco and the Phoenix heavy metal club, among other small businesses.

Currently, there is only one Wal-Mart store in the city, at North and Kilpatrick avenues on the West Side. Two others are set to open in 2012, in the Pullman Park development at 111th Street and the Bishop Ford Freeway, and at 83rd Street and Stewart Avenue in the Chatham neighborhood.

After the West Side store opened in 2006, expansion plans were put on hold when the City Council passed an ordinance that required big-box retailers to pay a minimum of $10 per hour and $3 hourly in benefits. Mayor Richard M. Daley vetoed the ordinance not long after it was passed.

Wal-Mart finally got the green light for expansion when it reached a deal with labor unions to set starting wages at $8.75 per hour, which is 50 cents less than unions had wanted.

  • weneedwork

    I don’t see Beal or Tunney handing out jobs on the street corner!

  • Jean SmilingCoyote

    Your story is remiss in not including a MAP showing this intersection and all the other businesses mentioned.

  • Jen Zak

    If Wal-mart coming in paying the same wages as it’s other stores it’s employees can not even afford to live in that neighborhood. It’s not going to create on local jobs.

    • Peter

      Walmart employees not able to affor to live in Lakeview? Well it’s not like the busboy at New Peking or a cashier at the Marketplace can afford it either. And besides I pretty much doubt the business like Stellas or your local grocery store pay better salaries and benefits than Walmart. That would be hard to believe.

  • Mike

    There is no such place as 111th and the Dan Ryan Expressway. Is it I-57 or I-94 Bishop Ford Expressway.

  • unknown

    if target wanted to be there people wouldn’t protest this much. they also pay their employees minimum wage and have no unions. i don’t understand the gap.

  • mara lee

    I am a resident of Lakeview and a homeowner. Neither myself nor any of my neighbors want Wal-Mart around and we will absolutely petition against it. There is nothing good that will come of Wal-Mart in our area. Our property values will go down, traffic will increase and the general quality of the neighborhood will undoubtedly decline. We will fight this tooth and nail.

    • M

      We would get a much needed grocery store.

  • V. Morin

    Seems like Wall Mart has a very poor site selection process. Lakeview demographics don’t point to Wall Mart shopper types. The store would be a lonely little onion in a petunia patch!

    • TomB

      Lakeview a petunia patch? Tell me how TJ Maxx, Marshalls and the Shoe Discount Warehouse contribute to the petunia patch??? Lakeview as it is not and has never been no Armitage, Oak Street or Wicker Park. There are so many onions already one more won’t make a difference!

  • George

    I love the wal-mart!

  • Bernadette

    That would totally blow chunks if Walmart moved into this space. Trader Joe’s would be a MUCH better option. It would serve as a much-needed alternative grocery store than stinking Walmart.

  • Francis

    Please help spread the word at

  • Wal-Mart Flap Enters Aldermanic Campaign « CBS Chicago – Breaking News, Sports, Weather, Traffic, and the Best of Chicago

    […] week, Winner posted on his Facebook page that he was “very concerned” about the possibility of a Wal-Mart coming to a vacant 30,000 square-foot space in the Broadway at Surf sh…, at 2840 N. Broadway just north of the busy Clark Street-Broadway-Diversey Parkway […]

  • Aberaham Liver

    Oh please naysayers – get over it. Walmart would be great for the area -and better maintained than the filthy Marshall’s store is. Property values won’t change because Walmart is there -although it should change because of all the pretentious folks who want to stop it

  • Podgląd Berkeley Wikileaks Rady Miejskiej Kontrowersje w następnym numerze | Convincing

    […] w ciągu 24 godzin sprawozdań planowanych sklepu. Czytaj więcej na rel=”nofollow” CBS Chicago This entry was posted in Bez kategorii and tagged Berkeley, Kontrowersje, Miejskiej, […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live