Spiegel: Best Rotation Of Our Lifetimes?

By Matt Spiegel, The Danny Mac Show–

Cliff Lee has turned down money to join what is the best starting pitching staff, on paper, I have ever seen. We’re not sure exactly how much he turned away…initial reports of 54 million dollars were a bit high. But still, to do what he wants, and to spurn the gluttonous pinstripes, well, it feels like a victory for all of us. (We’ll ignore the fact, for a moment, that it’s just another gluttonous team buying themselves the goods on the east coast.) We feel bad for Texas and Nolan Ryan, but we deeply enjoy this particular Yankees off-season. This choice comes from a guy who absolutely everyone thought would take the highest number, and be ruled by that number as much as anything else.

The sports, and the men, are vastly different, but there will be many who say Cliff Lee is being lauded for something LeBron James got torched for.

He chooses a chance to just be a part of something potentially great, instead of perhaps being the leader of the Rangers. He chooses support, chooses a collective. But he will not get ripped like LeBron for not wanting to go somewhere and be the man alone, and he shouldn’t be.

It’s not as necessary, or essential to the game itself, to have an alpha-dog in baseball. You can’t build a team around an ace quite the same way as you can a superstar in the NBA. In hoops, if you really want to be considered the greatest, the team has to be centered upon your skills. Cliff Lee has already gotten to the world series as “the man,” pitched well there and lost. He also pitched poorly there and lost. Now he gets more chances, probably for years to come. And here’s the biggest difference of all: Cliff Lee has not tried to sell himself as the best player in the league. A chosen one. We fans and blow-hards may have done that to him, but he hasn’t shoved it down our throats like the king of Akron did.

The Phillies top 4, on paper, is better than Smoltz, Maddux, Glavine, and Avery (swap Denny Neagle in there if you like). It’s better than Gooden, Darling, Sid Fernandez, and Bobby Ojeda. Is it better than Palmer, McNally, Dobson, and Cuellar? They won’t have four 20 game winners like that O’s team; the sport has changed too much of course. But how about quality starts as a staff? Remember, the quality start may seem feeble as a per-start measurement, but in a cumulative sense, the best in the league are always amongst the leaders.

The Phillies are still old in the field, with a power hitting hero who watched strike 3 to end his team’s season. The Giants beat Halladay, Oswalt (in relief), Hamels, and Lee (twice) in the post-season this past fall, so it can always be done.

I just wouldn’t want to be in the front office of any of the teams trying.

Apologies to the Cubs, who had no shot at the NL pennant anyway, and now even less. As for the White Sox? Lee stays out of the AL stretch run and playoffs. Outstanding.

More from Matt Spiegel
  • abe gibron's inevitable return

    I still like Jenkins, Holtzman, Hands and Pappas as the best foursome. Or even Wilbur Wood, Bahnsen, Wilbur Wood (on 2 days rest) and Jim Kaat.

  • randolph32

    Nice…just wish I was a Phillies fan so I could bask in the Winter limelight….

  • Anthony Effin Will

    I love it. Keep him out of the AL!!!



  • Anthony

    Great rotation on paper, destined for great things but I still say (homerism alert) the ’05 White Sox Staff of Buehrle, Contreras, Garland, and Garcia were the best I’VE ever witnessed. To go from start to finish in first place the whole way says so much about the starting pitching, not to mention all the complete games pitched throughout the playoffs/WS.


  • John Hatelak

    Atlanta’s staff is better on paper, statistically, and on record! Braves had three Cy Young condidates every year! You think Oswalt and Hamels are Cy young candidates? And don’t forget Kevin Millwood who I believe was a serious Cy young candidate at points in his career and may have had arguably the best stuff out of that group. Sorry Spiegs, but I have to respectfully disagree my man. And disagree by a wide margin. This group is good, but nowhere even close to that Atlanta staff.

  • bob

    The Cubs should thank their lucky stars, that they are not in that division. That will be suicide playing a 3 or 4 game series against them now……….

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live