Shepkowski: Consider Me ‘Sold’ On White Sox Closer Change

By Nick Shepkowski–

CHICAGO (WSCR) — Close games have not gone the White Sox way early in 2011, losing both one-run contests they’ve been in this year after falling 2-1 to the Oakland Athletics on Monday night. Wasted was a great outing by Mark Buehrle who went 8 scoreless innings and allowed only three base runners. One can argue that Buehrle should have been left in the game but the bigger problem sits in the White Sox closer.

Luck has been tough on Matt Thornton after Juan Pierre’s second ninth inning error in four days last night, but make no mistake about it; Thornton isn’t doing his part, either.

A quick look at Matt Thornton through four appearances this year shows an ERA of 2.45, plenty respectable in itself. A further glance shows an 0-1 record with three blown saves in as many chances. Even more concerning is the fact he has struck out only 2 of 21 batters faced this year, a rate of one every 10.5 batters faced, a number that is way down from the 1 SO per 3.97 batters faced in his career.

As you may have guessed, the lower strikeout totals have amounted in more base runners for opposing teams. In four appearances this season Thornton’s WHIP (Walks+Hits per Inning) sits at 2.727. By comparison the veteran lefty has managed a WHIP of just 1.171 in his first five seasons as a Chicago White Sox.

It seems obvious at this point that the “thing” baseball people often refer to with closers just hasn’t been there with Matt Thornton. Perhaps it comes with time and opportunities but it wouldn’t be the first time we’ve seen a great setup man fail as a closer in this town as bad memories of LaTroy Hawkins still sit in Cubs fans heads. 

People can sit back and blame Juan Pierre for two ninth inning defensive lapses in the past week, but there is no arguing the fact that Thornton has failed to pitch over mistakes. A lot of that is probably because he is still yet to develop a second pitch, as his changeup and slider have both yielded very poor results.

Correct me if I’m wrong but did Adam LaRoche not start the ninth inning by smoking a double to the left field gap? It shouldn’t have come as much surprise to White Sox fans who have seen three of four leadoff men Thornton has faced reach base this season. Had Paul Konerko not made an outstanding play on Coco Crisp a batter later the game would have been tied before an out was recorded, and it wasn’t Juan Pierre who fell behind 2-0 to Daric Barton before the fateful dropped fly-ball in left.

The season is young enough for the White Sox to make an effect change in the closer role and still be regarded as a legitimate contender to win the American League pennant. You have to look no further than Shingo Takatsu in 2005 for a closer who lost his job on a team that wound up winning a World Series. 

You can argue that it might crush Thornton’s confidence to remove him from the closer role, but what is being gained by him getting beat around the park each night in the ninth? If Chris Sale is the pitcher he is supposed to be then his move to closer should come sooner than later. 

Wins in April are just as valuable as those in August and September, and it’d be pretty difficult to be as bad as what we’ve seen in the ninth.

More from Nick Shepkowski
  • Ludes

    Every one of the 162 games counts the exact same. Any notions that they count more or less in April is silly. The Sox are 6-4 when they should be 9-1 or 8-2. Cleveland and KC are highly unlikely to play at .800 and .667 clips, respectively. That makes this all the more maddening because CWS could easily have a 4.5 game lead on Minnesota and 5 on the Tigers today (and 6 on potential ALCS foe, Boston). When September rolls around and the Sox are in a dogfight, we’ll think back to these few games as the ones that kept it close. Good job, Shep.

  • Eric

    Sox have to make a decision fast and make it now while the season is early.

    The “bad luck” means Thornton shouldn’t be in there in the first place as closer. He doesn’t have a closer mentality, the killer instinct. No matter what anybody says about Bobby Jenks, he had the closer mentality/killer instinct.

    Was Thornton given the role of closer just because of his seniority with the team?

  • Chris

    Correct me if I’m wrong but did Adam LaRoche not start the ninth inning by smoking a double to the left field gap?

    you’re wrong. it was Andy LaRoche


    It’s too early to pull the plug on the Matt Thornton experiment as closer of the Chicago White Sox. While Thornton now has 3 blown saves so far, the defense has definitely let Matt down in his last 2 save opportunities and it looks to me as if he’s thrown a lot more pitches than he should. If the White Sox are in a save situation tonight vs. the Rays, I wouldn’t be shocked if Ozzie goes back to Thornton. If Thornton continues to struggle in his new role for at least 2 more weeks or so, then a change may be necessary. I’m not so sure Chris Sale or Sergio Santos are better options at this stage for a bullpen that has resembled the Jim Carrey character “Fire Marshal Bill” on “In Living Color” instead of saving games like what Mark Buehrle had last night. Going 8 innings and shutting out the A’s last night, Buehrle deserved better than a no decision.

  • I blame the Cubs... or Gravity

    To Thornton closing the last few games; I haven’t seen the same pitcher I saw in previous years. The mentality of a batter changes when they are backed in a corner and a closer needs to be able to finish no matter what the situation is.

    I fully believe it is a confidence thing for Matt in that he is really trying to fill that role, but it seems he is trying to hard and not just going out there and letting it rip, which he does so well.

    I really believe it is the pressure of the situation that is getting to him. Not by rattling him or anything like that but by the batters on the other team stepping it up that much more in their last at bats.

  • Most popular Chicago White Sox Information – Adam Dunn eyes Sunday return to Chicago White Sox lineup

    […] Read more on CBS Chicago […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live