Holmes’ Morning After Blog: ‘All In’ Means Making Tough Decisions

By Laurence W. Holmes–

(WSCR) It’s time for the Sox to live up to their marketing slogan. The usual crutch of Interleague Play has netted them a 7-6 record thus far, and a grueling 19-game stretch inside the A.L. Central is on the horizon. Some hard questions need to be asked of the entire White Sox organization: Is everyone selling out to get wins? Are the White Sox all pulling on the same rope? It doesn’t seem that way, especially when you have to wonder if the best 25 guys are on the roster.

Dayan Viciedo is healthy and tearing the cover off the ball in Charlotte: Viciedo is hitting over .330. He’s getting on base 37% of the time and has 12 home runs and 55 runs batted in. He’s ready for a return to the majors. The White Sox needs some pop, and Viciedo, at least, has the potential to give that to them. The Sox have been impressed with how he’s progressed as an outfielder. The problem lies in who would have to leave to make space for Viciedo. There is more than one candidate.

There’s been much discussion since the beginning of the season about Juan Pierre’s diminishing skills. Tuesday night not withstanding, Pierre has struggled. He hasn’t been a table setter (.315 OBP). He hasn’t been a base stealer (10/19). In fact he hasn’t had a stolen base in 19 straight games. He hasn’t played a solid left field (5 errors and .970 fielding position at the easiest position on the diamond). Pierre makes for an target, but he isn’t the only one.

Gordon Beckham has not shown the same promise, offensively, that he did in the second half of last year, or when he was first called up. To his credit, he’s become a very solid second baseman defensively, and that should be considered. For most of this season, Beckham has looked lost at the plate and isn’t providing any offense. In his last 11 games, he’s hitting .154 and he needed two hits last night at Coors Field to get there. He has options left and perhaps his meteoric rise to the majors was a detriment after all. If you were to send him down you could play Brent Lillibridge at second base and have him leadoff. Bench Pierre and play Viciedo in left field.

Omar Vizquel shouldn’t be safe on “White Sox Island” either. Last year, his contribution was immense. He hit the ball. He provided defensive stability at third base and played a role in developing Alexei Ramirez into a gold-glove caliber shortstop. This year, Vizquel has been OK: .271/.298/.336, but he hasn’t been untouchable. If he were playing as well as last year, you could justify him being on the roster instead of Viciedo, but this year, you can’t.

The biggest problem seems to be that Kenny Williams and Ozzie Guillen can’t agree on what the winning formula is. There is also the issue of loyalty. It’s fair to ask the question: Is Pierre’s continued presence on this team due to the fact that Guillen has genuine affection for the hardworking veteran? It’s also fair to ask: Is Beckham’s roster spot safe due to the fact that Williams doesn’t want to pull the plug on such a highly regarded prospect?

Williams and Guillen have always been better together than apart. It’s time to get on the same page. They need to have a serious talk about the immediate future of this team. The Sox have spent the most money in franchise history putting this bunch together. That being said, the money shouldn’t be a factor when it comes to roster spots, or spots in the lineup. Either you’re trying to win now or you aren’t. There may be some hurt feelings if Pierre, Beckham or Vizquel go, but the division is on the line. “All In” means making tough decisions. If those decisions aren’t made the Sox are going to find themselves “All Out” of the A.L. Central race.

More from Laurence Holmes
  • Bronzo

    2 things Laurence…

    The “Morning After Blog” being posted at 2;01 pm cst doesn’t make it a a ‘Morning Blog’ it’s afternoon. Secondly you make some obvious points about the Sox’ lineup and who Viciedo could replace.

    So who is your pick to sit?

    I say he could sub for a few people …he can take turns playing for Pierre and Rios and maybe even have a few stints at DH..Sure couldn’t hurt. And Vizquel is the odd man out.

  • Jim O'Shea

    LoHo – This team is done. They have lost the 1st game of the last 5 series. They should be making “Hay” against the National League, but they cannot score with RISP. The pitching has been above average all year – except for Thorton’s early struggles. Do you really think adding Viciedo is going to push this team into contention? They have had that carrot dangling in front of them for the last 3 weeks and cannot even break .500. ALL IN – how about ALL DUNN! Ha – LOL!


    When the White Sox do call up Dayan Viciedo, whether in time for the second Cubs’ series at Wrigley Field this weekend or September 1st when rosters expand, there are a couple of things to consider in my opinion. First, Viciedo will be playing right field, not left. Carlos Quentin, who currently plays RF would return to LF where he originally played when he arrived in that trade about 3 years ago with the Arizona Diamondbacks and Juan Pierre would be sent packing. Second, what if Viciedo joins other current White Sox on this uneven roster and can’t translate the offensive production he’s currently doing for Triple “A” Charlotte? That being said, Ozzie has said all along that once Viciedo arrives, he plays everyday.

    As far as leading off is concerned, once Pierre is released, it’s not the most ideal situation once Pierre is waived or given his unconditional release. As much as Sox fans want to see Brent Lillibridge in the lineup, be careful what you wish for. Lillibridge has spent most of the season in the outfield instead of his natural positions by trade of shortstop and second base. Like many of his Sox teammates right now, #18’s starting to struggle at the plate himself when Ozzie puts him in the lineup mostly vs. left-handers. While the Sox can lead off Lillibridge in those situations, the way this roster is currently constructed and with SS Alexei Ramirez batting noticeably lower in RBI spots lately, the only other regular Ozzie may have to lead off once Pierre is sent packing is 2B Gordon Beckham. This despite the disappointing BA & low on-base percentage Beckham currently has. It remains to be seen what happens, but for a team that is supposed to be “ALL IN”, it’s put up or shut up time.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live