Pearlman Defends Writing Payton Book

(WSCR) Since an excerpt of Jeff Pearlman’s new book, “Sweetness: The Enigmatic Life of Walter Payton,” was published in Sports Illustrated Wednesday, the author has come under fire for writing details many believe are no one’s business.

Friday, Pearlman defended himself in an appearance on The Mully and Hanley Show on 670 The Score.

“If you’re writing a biography — a true, definitive biography of someone’s life — and you find out (Payton) had a son and then you find out he had a son that he wasn’t involved with, it’s painful, yes. Is it enjoyable to write? It honest to God is not,” Pearlman said. “But I don’t know — if you want to be honest and definitive about someone’s life — (if you can) ignore it. And that’s sort of my stance when I write a book.”

LISTEN: Jeff Pearlman on The Mully and Hanley Show

Pearlman, a former baseball writer for Sports Illustrated, insists he had no knowledge of Payton’s transgressions before he started writing the book.

“My exposure to Walter Payton came one time,” Pearlman said. “It was when he was dying back in ’99, I flew out to his office and spent 30 minutes talking to him about his illness. I swear to you on the lives of my kids, and I have two of them, that I knew nothing about this before I started this project. Nothing.”

The response to the book has been mostly negative in Chicago. Former Bears head coach Mike Ditka said he would spit on Pearlman. Tom Thayer said Friday on 670 The Score that he would not read the book and he doesn’t respect it. For what it’s worth, Pearlman said he interviewed Ditka for the book.

The author also wanted to make it clear that the negative facts of Payton’s life are just one part of the book.

“If you read the book, the whole book, it is much more sort of like the Vince Lombardi biography, ‘When Pride Still Mattered’ or the great (Roberto) Clemente biography by David Maraniss, than it is a slash job on Walter Payton. I guarantee you,” Pearlman said. “But all people have is the excerpt. If you read the book — and people think, ‘Oh, he’s trying to make a buck,’ take it out from the library, stand in Barnes & Noble and read it, I don’t care — if you read the book, you’ll see it is a definitive biography of his entire life and this part of his life about his retirement, a very, very dark period in his life, is one part of the book.”

More from The Mully and Hanley Show
  • Just Checking

    So it’s not important who we are, but who we seem to be? Spit on that.

  • FC

    What’s the big deal? We all knew he was an addict. This is nothing new or revealing. Hope you people didn’t think he was this clean-cut sports-model who needed to be admired. He was none of that. A great player indeed. An untouchable “god” he wasn’t. Enough already, please.

  • Roberta Waker

    Don’t buy the book!!! Walter was a great player, a good husband and father, so why slander a dead man that isn’t here to defend himself? “Let he who is without sin cast the first stone.” We prefer to remember him as “sweetness” and that will NOT change. Keep your book, Mr. Pearlman – I hope someone does a really good tell all bio on you when you die. Let Walter rest in peace.

  • zarathrusta

    Jock sniffers unite! Rise up and defend another overpaid doper who wouldn’t give you the time of day.

  • Jefferson Davis

    These Negro slaves need a good horsewhipping.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live