Judge Will Hold Hearing On Cellini Juror’s Failure To Disclose Felony Convictions

CHICAGO (CBS) — Springfield power broker William Cellini won’t get an automatic mistrial after learning that a juror in his corruption trial failed to disclose her criminal record before being picked for the jury, but a federal judge will hold a hearing on the matter.

U.S. District Judge James Zagel ruled Wednesday that the fact a female juror was convicted of at least two felonies does not mean the jury’s verdict should be thrown out automatically.

Cellini’s attorneys have filed a motion seeking a mistrial over the juror’s undisclosed felony convictions, but prosecutors have argued that felony convictions in Illinois do not automatically exclude someone from serving on a jury.

In a written order on Wednesday, Zagel said the “issue bears brief discussion” and ruled that a hearing will be held on or after Dec. 1.

Zagel said the only question to answer is whether the defense can prove any “actual bias” from the juror’s failure to disclose her felony convictions on her jury questionnaire and during questioning in court.

“When a felon slips through the juror screening process, does that felon’s service on the jury lead to automatic mistrial? Every federal court of appeal that has addressed this issue has answered ‘no,’” Zagel wrote. “Instead, the courts of appeal have held that the proper course of action is to hold an evidentiary hearing where the defendant has an opportunity to prove ‘actual bias.’”

The judge also held that Cellini’s defense must be able to cast sufficient doubt on the juror’s impartiality in order to declare a mistrial.

“Much hinges on the nature and credibility of the juror’s explanation for uttering a falsehood,” Zagel wrote. “If the juror offers an innocent explanation that is simply not credible, then bias may be shown and a new trial should be granted. … If, on the other hand, a juror offers a bias-free explanation which the courts find credible – such as confusion or embarrassment about admitting to felony convictions before a large audience in open court – then bias cannot be presumed.”

It’s up to the judge in each individual case in federal court as to whether the court should run background checks on potential jurors.

In most cases, background checks are not conducted, except in high-profile cases.

Zagel had background checks done on the jury pool for the first trial and the retrial of former Gov. Rod Blagojevich, but in Cellini’s case, no background checks were done.

–Todd Feurer, CBS 2 Web Producer

  • Jim Hamilton

    I have a dream too

    DECATUR, Ill. (CBS) — A downstate lawmaker would like to kick Chicago and Cook County out of the Illinois.
    CBS 2 Political Producer Ed Marshall says state Rep. Bill Mitchell (R-Decatur) finds that Cook County dominates all politics and legislation in Springfield, and he thinks it is time for the state to cut its largest population center adrift for the “betterment” of the rest of Illinois.
    He says Cook County should be allowed to exist apart from the state like the District of Columbia, with its own government.

    Contact your local Reps to support this bill


  • righttrack

    Why wouldn’t the Clerk Of Courts screen these potential jurors, or at least do a background check after they are picked for the jury ???

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live