Refunds Ordered For Moms Towed From Improperly Marked Lot

CHICAGO (CBS) — It’s been said it’s easier to take a steak from a bear than it is to get a refund from a Chicago towing company, but that’s exactly what a group of North Side moms achieved.

As CBS 2’s Derrick Blakley reports, a CBS 2 story last week played a big role in getting the moms what they wanted.

Meghann Sarnicki said she never really expected to get a refund after she and several other mothers complained about their cars getting towed from a Lincoln Park lot, even though warning signs were not clearly visible at the entrance to the parking lot.

Sarnicki and Jade Benning said they wouldn’t accept what they saw as an act of blatant abuse by Phillips Towing.

On Jan. 24, they were enjoying a playdate with their children at Little Beans Café, which combines coffee for parents with playtime for toddlers.

In the middle of their playdate, the mothers were told their cars were being towed out of the neighboring parking lot, which they’d been using for months.

Sarnicki’s and Benning’s cars, and eight other cars were towed from a giant lot next door to the café. Little Beans customers had been parking there since last June, when the neighboring building was torn down, but had never had a problem before.

Benning said “because it affected so many people and the way that it was done, I really hoped they would right a wrong.”

Although there were warning signs posted at the lot, they were placed only at the very back end of the lot where drivers who entered the lot from Webster Avenue could not see them, much less read them.

It cost each of the mothers $200 to get their cars back.

“It smells a lot like a set-up, from all the circumstances that I’ve heard,” Sarnicki said.

After the moms had their cars towed, the café immediately put up their own signs warning customers not to park in the neighboring parking lot or they’d be towed.

Two days later, a day after CBS 2 aired a story about the mothers’ plight, an Illinois Commerce Commission investigator paid a visit to the lot and apparently determined the signs were improper.

The agency ordered Phillips towing to give refunds to everyone who got towed.

“I called the towing company and told them my name and they said, ‘Yes … we refunded your card.’ It was two days later, so it was fast,” Benning said.

A spokesperson for the Illinois Commerce Commission said Phillips Towing was issued a citation and could be fined for the incident. They’ve also been told they can’t tow any more cars from that lot until proper signs are installed near the entrance.

The towing company’s general manager, Mary Ann Phillips, said 10 cars were towed from the lot and she agreed it was improper to tow the vehicles because the signs were not adequate.

More from Derrick Blakley
  • Me

    I guess the blind squirrel does find an acorn every once in a while. Congrats ladies for beating the odds and getting refunded your expenses.

  • Gabby Espinosa

    There is nothing more annoying than a SAH mom on a mission.

  • No Hope For The Young

    If you dont have a clue, stay at home and watch the soaps.

  • James

    Nice to see some justice.

  • Tow Company Refunds Lincoln Park Ladies |

    […] Read the CBS 2 account, “Refunds Ordered For Moms Towed From Improperly Marked Lot.” […]

  • mikey donuts

    I feel bad for the towing company for once. What a load a BS

  • Thelma Mosher

    I am happy that they got there money back. For all you people making negative remarks, I am sure that if this happened to you, you would of been complaining until you got your money back. So put your selves in the moms shoes and think (what if this happened to me what would I do?) I am sure you would of done the same thing.

  • WOW

    Thelma….learn proper grammar!!! Your post is atrocious!

  • juju

    nice to see people being taken advantage by their own kind.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live