Court Filing: Responding Officers Omitted Details In Abbate Case

CHICAGO (CBS) — Papers filed in federal court in the case of a female bartender whose 2007 beating by an off-duty Chicago Police officer was caught on tape indicate police left some information out of the initial report.

As WBBM Newsradio’s Mike Krauser reports, Karolina Obrycka said she told the responding officers she was beaten by Officer Anthony Abbate and that she gave the officers his full name. She also says it was all caught on tape.


LISTEN: WBBM Newsradio’s Mike Krauser reports

Obrycka claims the officers omitted Abbate’s name from the report because they didn’t want to deal with him.

The City of Chicago is disputing that Obyrcka provided Abbate’s name, but acknowledges she did say her attacker was a police officer, and that it was caught on tape.

The responding officers later said they couldn’t recall if they knew at the time the attacker was a cop. Both were disciplined, but the city denies they lied so as to protect a fellow police officer.

The city did admit that the Independent Police Review Authority did find the officers violated a department rule, but didn’t specify what penalty, if any, they received.

Abbate attacked Obrycka, who is half his size, on Feb. 19, 2007, when she refused to serve him more drinks at Jesse’s Shorstop Inn, 5425 W. Belmont Ave.

Abbate was initially charged with simple battery, but the charges were upgraded to felony aggravated battery after the surveillance video of the attack went became a national sensation. He was also accused of trying to bribe Obrycka to keep quiet.

While Abbate’s actions had few defenders, some, including many rank-and-file police officers, said the attack only constituted simple battery and that the charges were only upgraded because Abbate was a police officer.

The fallout from the attack eventually led Supt. Phil Cline to resign. He was replaced by FBI veteran Jody Weis, who in turn was supplanted by current Supt. Garry McCarthy.

Observers also complained when Criminal Court Judge John Fleming sentenced Abbate to probation and spared him prison time in 2009.

Abbate was fired from the Police Department when he was convicted.

  • tom sharp

    Anyone that believes these cops is a moron.

  • Anthony Ellis

    Only in Chicago are certan people allowed to be above the law itself.

  • Jim Beam

    I wonder where Anthony is drinkin now?

  • Joe

    I can’t believe they are drudging this case up again. I thought it was done and over with. What he did was wrong and he received his punishment, end of story. It’s obvious that the charges were upgraded only because he was a cop. This whole thing should be laid to rest.

  • Clarence Sutton

    Received punishment ? I don’t think so , if he was a regular person or a minority I wonder what his sentence would’ve been I bet it would not have been probation !!

    • Joe

      What do you think they do with people who commit assault? There was no weapon and she walked away afterwards. A regular person would have also received probation. If it had been a negro commiting the crime, he most likely would have been guilty of many more violent acts and would have also robbed the place afterwards. Not a good comparison!!!

      • Sam

        As any crime committed to an officer is deemed a felony, any crime committed by an officer should be automatically deemed a felony.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live