Spiegel: Tebow-Lin Comparison Needs To Stop Immediately

By Matt Spiegel-

(CBS) I’ve been watching a lot of people progressively get grumpier about Jeremy Lin.

Look, I can empathize a bit with that knee-jerk reaction to the flavor of the moment.  Make something the SportsCenter lead four days in a row and people will snipe.  Include him in a poll asking who the best player in the NBA is and the vaguely intelligent will grumble.  But that knee-jerk kickback impulse should always be counterbalanced with a simple question to yourself: Is this attention actually warranted?

Or more directly for our line of interest: Does the player or team involved show true excellence?

See, there are a ton of people, columnists, writers, tweeters, pundits, Score texters and friends of yours that suddenly hate Jeremy Lin and his story with the same attitude and zealous dismissal with which they hated Tim Tebow and his story. The direct comparison between those two men and their narrative arcs has been made repeatedly, and lazily.  You’ve seen it.  Hell, there are columns on this website about exactly that.  Verve has been found to root against Lin and the Knicks because of his “similarities” to Tebow.  What is similar is the reactionary response, and not remotely the phenomena themselves.

Lin and Tebow have dominated professional sports media at times within the last six months and they share an obvious faith in God.

And that’ll do it folks. Goodnight everybody.

Is that enough for you, really?

I find it’s often useful to go back to, you know, the sports of it.  Remember sports?

The athletic essence of the tales is such:  Tim Tebow was one of the most sought after high school footballers in the country. Jeremy Lin (despite being the best high school player in California) was offered zero college scholarships.  Zero, even though he lived essentially across the street from his dream school of Stanford.  At Florida, Tebow won two BCS titles and a Heisman trophy. At Harvard, Lin was quietly brilliant and I read an article about him in Sports Illustrated once. You may have caught a single buzzer-beater highlight a couple times.  Tebow was an anointed, endlessly hyped first round draft pick who soared on fan pressure to get his perhaps unwarranted chance. The undrafted Lin is on his third NBA team THIS YEAR and saw garbage minutes for weeks as the rudderless Knicks sputtered.  And most importantly, Tebow and the Broncos succeeded while he played mediocre if not flat out terrible at quarterback. Lin has been the best point guard in a great point guard league for two weeks. There is no grand experiment being carried out in which the very fabric of the game is being questioned here either.  Emulating Bobby Douglass is one thing, doing a Steve Nash impression is another.

Lin wasn’t sitting on the bench as fans chanted his name for weeks like Tebow, until the organization had no choice but to give him his shot.  Lin was nowhere, no one.  This is a top tier producer amidst the best athletes in the world who Kobe Bryant had genuinely never heard of.

If you need more, go ahead and get personal.  Is it that hard to look deeper at these guys?  Tebow is a home-schooled, impossibly naïve mass of pure earnestness (I stand forever by my comparison to him as “Buddy the Elf.”)  Lin is a Palo Alto high school, Harvard-educated rational and thoughtful interview.  If you felt proselytized to by Tebow, has Lin really done the same?  Is any mention of his faith, which he believes is fundamental to his personal success, an affront?  Lin has in no way put God front and center of every postgame and pregame (in the considerable volume of content I’ve seen), maybe cognizant of the sidetracking and counterproductive effects of Tebow’s declarations.

If you’re one who says “Linsanity is just like Tebowmania!” and hope for his failure, then what you’re really saying is that you just don’t like popular things.  You are allowing yourself to be willfully cynical by default, just resenting a classic rags to riches sports story.  I hated lots of popular bands at different times earlier in my musical appreciation life because they were… popular.  But then I grew up just enough, actually listened to some of them, thought about it, and hated the ones that merited it.  You see, good is good.  Just because I thought N’Sync was awful and popular didn’t mean Justin Timberlake solo couldn’t be very good and popular.  I think Nickelback sucks because they suck, not because they sell out arenas.  And if that purely headline-induced cynicism is your mode here, one can then freely question whether it was your mode with Tebow too, despite what you might have found and clung to as justifiable rationale.

Bitter anti-Lin rooters have to justify their leanings in a new way, a different way, a REAL way.  Hate the pick-and-roll point guard game?  Fine.  Think he’ll be dominated by Rose, Paul, Deron and Nash?  Okay.  Believe defenses will adjust to his tendencies?  Let’s go ahead and debate it.  I personally think Mike D’Antoni is a hack, and that Lin is benefiting greatly as this year’s system creation, like an Ivy League Raymond Felton.  I can’t wait to see if he’s good enough to maintain some excellence as the league sees him over and over.

Just don’t hate Jeremy because Timmy drove you Linsane.

Matt Spiegel is the co-host of The McNeil & Spiegel Show weekdays from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. on 670 The Score. Follow him on Twitter at @MattSpiegel670.

More from Matt Spiegel
  • Joe Kallenbach

    really good comparison to popular bands. except nickelback is awesome don’t hate

  • Bernstein's buddy

    Somewhere B&B are looking at each other saying, “what we are actually supposed to be talking about sports?” They think hating everything and making gay jokes is what drives the public.

  • Marky Mark

    Spiegs, I think you’re confusing the comparison. The ridiculous amount of media coverage and hype are what people are lashing back at, and where people are drawing the comparisons to Tebow. Couple that with the fact that no other player in the league has been NEAR the news story this year based on their play, even though this kid’s only started five games. Whether you believe it or not, some of us actually want to enjoy sports simply to watch the best athletes in the world play games, not for any feel-good stories that “news” organizations feel they need to stuff down our throats repeatedly.

    People are tired of the constant-coverage act, the overblown polling questions, the “should the Knicks trade Melo?” questions, and the “will Melo and STAT keep Lin down when they return?” questions. Let us appreciate the kid’s game, inform us why he’s had success, break down what it is about his game that allows him to thrive, and where his shortcomings might come back to bite him. I know you follow Jason Goff on Twitter, and I think his breakdown of Lin’s game has been perfect. All of the ESPN story garbage is just fluff, and frankly, I don’t need that with my sports. I don’t think anyone actually hates or can’t stand Lin himself, unlike with Tebow, just the over coverage without any real breakdown.

    It frustrates me as a basketball fan in general that during every game I’ve watched since Lin’s game against the Lakers he has been worked into the broadcast. Not to mention that I can’t turn on ESPN without hearing about him within five minutes, with each poll question more ridiculous than the next. It’s been four days and I’m already worn out by it.

  • Reo

    great article, fresh perspective

  • Mark Nielsen

    For a hard-hitting, softhearted, humorously serious comparison of Lin’s rise with that of Tim Tebow, Big Z and other evangelical Christian athletes (with the bonus of big props to Score faves Boers and Bernstein), take your “hops” on over here –>

    Thanks for the giddily fuming debate, Matt!

  • Mark Nielsen

    For a hard-hitting, softhearted, humorously serious comparison of Lin’s rise with that of Tim Tebow, Big Z and other evangelical Christian athletes (with the bonus of big props to Score faves Boers and Bernstein), take your “hops” on over here –>


    Thanks for the giddily fuming debate, Matt!

    • Mark Nielsen

      sorry for dupe… tech problem didnt let me see first one right away

  • John Lee

    There is no comparison. Jeremy Lin can actually play the point. Tim Tebow is a god awful qb. Tim Tebow was a high school all american, heisman trophy winner, ncaa champion. Jeremy Lin undrafted. Jeremy Lin came out of nowhere to do what he’s doing.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live