CBS 2 Chicago wbbm7801059 670 The Score

Cantankerous Critic: ‘Valor’ Not Valiant, Just Stupid

View Comments
'Act Of Valor'

M 076 Lt. Rorke fires at the QRF (quick reactionary force) in Relativity’s Media’s upcoming release, “Act of Valor”. (Credit: IATM LLC/Relativity Media)

Don't Miss This

“Act of Valor”
Rated PG-13
Grade: D+

By MICHAEL WALTERS
Cantankerous Critic

“Act of Valor” is a lunkheaded Naval recruitment video that wears its narrative ineptness on its chest as a badge of honor and values its poor performances as a sign of “authenticity.” It’s so simplistic it makes G.I. Joe look like Hamlet.

The film began as a short training video, and was then expanded by a two man directing team known as the bandito brothers who shoot and edit this movie as though they’d just gotten their first cameras for Christmas.

According to the New York Times, this movie came to the screen as part of a Naval recruitment initiative, and it sounds like it was written by low level government hacks in the pentagon. The film allegedly stars “real” active duty Navy SEALS, but they’re shoehorned into a plot that’s all Hollywood, and bad Chuck Norris action picture Hollywood at that.

After a violent prologue involving the fiery death of dozens of innocent children, the film gets down to business as the Navy SEALS are sent to Costa Rica to extract a CIA agent being tortured by an oily South American drug kingpin and part time gun runner. They also have to stop a mad Chechen Muslim bomber out to push the American government into complete chaos.

The navy SEALs are lionized so constantly they practically arrive on the battlefield sporting halos along with their weaponry. Every Navy SEAL is a fearless warrior tirelessly sacrificing everything to protect their country from a variety of forces aimed at the very destruction of America. While the film prides itself on its liberal use of military jargon, but what may please the pentagon doesn’t leave audiences with much of a story to go on. And its bread and butter action sequences ring hollow. The game has been rigged, and everything has the look and feel of a training exercise where the stakes are low- even though the filmmakers had access to a variety of real high tech weaponry including a nuclear sub.

There’s no question real Navy SEALs are real American heroes, and they deserve credit for stealthily pulling off daring acts of bravery. But this movie is one mission that frankly isn’t worth their time.

View Comments
  • Anit-Critic

    What does a movie critic truly know about a good movie? They repeatedly raise praise to awful movies and pan good ones. A D+ from this mook tells me which movie I’ll be watching this weekend.

  • Stevan

    Often people like most liberals in the media, are so caught up in their mindless dribble cult mentality that nothing the say can seriously be believed or supported!! As a point of fact previous comment alluded to the fact that he judges a good movie by a D+ rating from this critic.. You probably think Matt Damion is a good actor huh? Rofl You leftist are so out of touch with the world around You, You have become that which You disdained in the 60s!!! Before You judge me as a conservative, be advised i do not bow to any belief, political or religious.. If a person in the media or politics has been involved in any part of a thought it is FUBAR from its beginning..

    • Anti-Critic

      I do think Mr Damon is a good actor. He is also a good writer and obviously an intelligent person in script selection…for the most part. Does that mean my view of the D+ as a recommendation is tainted?

      I saw Valor this weekend. I enjoyed it. You could tell who the non-actors were. Didn’t hurt the film though. I didn’t see any political message and didn’t feel it was a recruitment flick in the least.

      • Stevan

        Forgive me for my error in judgment. I have a total of 14 years in the Air Force and the Army. I have trained with Marines, Rangers, and been Blessed with talking to some Seals. I am a bit hyper sensitive to those who mindlessly downgrade persons in the military.. The people i have met and trained with are not murders,or evil in any way. Just pure hearted warriors protecting and serving those who need to be protected and served.. Whether they deserve to be or not.

        Again forgive me for my little brain fart..

      • Anti-Critic

        Not a problem. Thought you were a blow-hard, but I erred in my judgement of you too. We’re all human.

        i have not been part of the military, never felt the desire. I wholey support the work they do defending this Nation and others. I know they are murders or thugs.

        God Bless and Protect the Military (US and others)

        BTW…I had to contact my brother after your first post to see if was his post…his name is Stevan (with an A) and doesn’t like the leftist media either.

      • Stevan

        That is so funny. Stevan with an a is not often used.. What i wish everyone would understand about the Military and serving, You do as You are ordered, without question (for the most part).. It is politicians that cause war, it is politicians that cause death in war.. I have not once in all my years as a soldier found another soldier who enjoyed taking another humans life… When You do You take from them everything they are, have been and ever will be, and You carry each for the rest of Your life..

        Yell and scream at the supposed educated politicians for their misguided ways, and the Department of State croniies that set the world on fire with their greed.. Then when it gets out of hand thrust poor and middle class warriors into the fray to clean up their errors.

        A world of peace would be a wonderful thing indeed, but since beginning of time man has been at war in one way or another.. Only problem with it in Our age warfare is so damn efficient sad to say…

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

RSS Most Popular News

Follow CBS Chicago

Like us on foursquare

RSS Contests & Promotions

  • Win $1,000 In Gas From Hyundai! June 17, 2013
    Enter to win $1,000 in free gas from Hyundai! What’s better than free gas? How about the 2013 Elantra Limited with an EPA-Estimated 38 MPG Highway! 28 City/38 Hwy. EPA Estimates. For comparison only. Actual mileage may vary.
  • Join Hankook Tire To Reel In The Next Big Catch May 20, 2013
    Join Hankook tire to reel in the next great catch! Click here to go to www.TirePrize.com and enter for your chance to win the ultimate fishing excursion in Puerto Rico!
  • Marquette County Convention & Visitors Bureau Post Game Show Giveaway May 10, 2013
    Listen to The Score’s Baseball Post Game Show for your chance to win a $100 lodging gift certificate from the Marquette County Convention & Visitors Bureau!
  • Enjoy Golf’s Best Round With GREY GOOSE Vodka May 1, 2013
    Enjoy Golf’s Best Round this season with GREY GOOSE Vodka! Visit your participating retailer today and purchase one 750 mL or larger bottle of GREY GOOSE Vodka to receive one free round of golf!
WBBM Newsradio 780, Radio Stations & Broadcast Companies, Chicago, IL

Twitter Updates