2 Investigators: Officer Shot Suspect In Back Of Head, Casting Doubt On Cop's Story
(CBS) – During a traffic stop last July, Chicago police shot a man in the back of the head. His family calls the shooting unjustified. Now, they've filed a wrongful death lawsuit to get answers.
CBS 2's Pam Zekman reports.
A recording of the police radio that night tells part of the story: "Emergency! Shots fired by the police -- 10639 South Cottage Grove."
There were no cameras at the shooting scene where Eugene McSwain, a 26-year-old wanted on an Indiana burglary warrant, died. But because police reports conflict with other evidence, McSwain's father hired an attorney to file a lawsuit.
"In many ways this case is just like the Laquan McDonald case, where a police officer shoots someone in a highly questionable manner," attorney James Montgomery Jr. says.
McSwain was in the passenger seat of a truck. According to police reports, he reached under the seat, pulled out a gun and pointed it at a police officer.
This begs a question: If the officer was in fear for his life because McSwain was pointing a gun at him, how did the suspect end up with a bullet in the back of his head?
"That is the million dollar question, because that's impossible, and that's what we're going to ask the police officer during this lawsuit," Montgomery said. "It didn't happen that way."
A cell phone and gun were found on the truck's floorboard.
According to the Citizens Police Data Project, the officer, Detective Gary Bush, has had nine complaints in recent years. Three involved use of force, four involved illegal searches. All of them were unsustained.
Police reports in the McSwain case show eight officers at the scene used identical words that they were "in fear of great bodily harm and death" and that McSwain pointing a gun at them posed a threat.
"Once again, we're faced with we don't know who to believe about what, when the police write reports. And the public deserves far more than that, and certainly the family of Eugene McSwain Jr. deserves more than that," Montgomery says.
"I'm furious. I'm angry. I'm upset, disappointed in how the system is going now," says Eugene McSwain Sr., the father of the shooting victim. "There's too many trigger-happy police officers now."
Officer Bush did not respond to CBS 2's attempts to reach him. The Chicago Police Department declined to comment on the case, which is still pending with the Independent Police Review Authority.
