Scooter’s Frozen Custard
1658 W. Belmont Ave.
Chicago, IL 60657
For fresh, creamy and smooth ice cream unlike any other, head to Scooter’s in Roscoe Village. Here they call it frozen custard, but that’s just another word for the best ice cream ever. Plus, frozen custard is made a bit differently than your traditional ice cream; to be considered authentic custard, it must contain 1.4% egg yolk and at least 10% butterfat. It also is produced with a process that uses less ice cream, creating fewer ice crystals. But the only thing you really need to know is this: Pick either vanilla or chocolate frozen custard and then your choice of a stunning array of mix-ins, including butterfinger, mocha, sprinkles, chocolate chip cookie dough, and the list goes on and on. In other words, ice cream heaven.
1960 N. Western Ave.
Chicago, IL 60647
Established in 1921, Margie’s Candies in Logan Square is an institution known for just about every dessert there is, including a variety of ice cream options, and today the shop is run by a fourth-generation Poulos family member. If you have a super big sweet tooth—or you’re willing to share — check out the amazing jumbo options. All include hefty scoops of ice cream and come with an array of toppings. One of the many favorites? The turtle sundae, which comes with three scoops of ice cream, as well as caramel pecans, and fudge, all topped with whipped cream, cherry and a cookie.
2867 N. Milwaukee Ave.
Chicago, IL 60618
Mexican-inspired ice cream? Yes, please! The flavors here may sound crazy—after all, you can get avocado ice cream—but it’s one of the most delightful and interesting ice cream experiences you’ll have in the city. In addition to the avocado flavor, there’s also 35 other flavors to choose from, meaning you can have an entire Mexican feast through ice cream, from appetizers to dessert! For those seeking something a tad more traditional, Delicias Natural also offers a fabulous Mexican chocolate ice cream.
Related: Best Ice Cream Sundaes in Chicago
630 W. 26th St.
Chicago, IL 60616
For one of the most decadent ice cream desserts, look no further than this Bridgeport hot spot. While it also has Italian ice, ice cream, soft serve, sundaes, and malts—in other words, plenty of dessert options—it’s the funnel cake sundae that makes this place famous. If you’re enjoying your dessert alone, opt for the mini for $4.50. Sharing? Grab the enormous full size for just $7.25. Either options include vanilla soft serve, one wet topping (like hot fudge or peanut butter), one dry topping (with options ranging from granola to fruity pebbles) and whipped cream, and is finished with a cherry on top!
9233 S. Western Ave.
Chicago, IL 60643
Established in 1926, the Original Rainbow Cone in Beverly is one of the oldest ice cream shops in Chicago (other than Margie’s, of course). But that’s not the only thing that makes this family-run shop so special. Rather, just as the name implies, it’s all about the unbelievable and sugary delight that is the rainbow cone. Whether ordered in a cup or a cone, the rainbow comes in, you guessed in, a plethora of colors and flavors, including chocolate, strawberry, Palmer House, pistachio, and orange sherbet. This rainbow of flavors is also available as a cake. Other flavors, as well as shakes, are available, but it’s the rainbow cone that has made this place popular for decades, and decades to come.
Related: Best Doughnuts In Chicago