CBS 2 Chicago wbbm7801059 670 The Score

Local

2 Investigators Expose Storm Damage Scams

Send Your Tips To Dave Savini

View Comments
Chris Skedd

Chris Skedd, a worker for Blue Rose Restoration, a storm damage inspection company, was caught on-camera making dents into the aluminum siding of a home. (CBS)

From 2 Investigators

Don't Miss This

AURORA, Ill. (CBS) – After heavy wind and hail storms strike, storm chasers quickly move in with offers to fix what they say is damage to your home. Consumers have to be careful because that damage may not be storm-related.

CBS 2 Investigator Dave Savini exposes a type of scam that is most common in Illinois, and costing all homeowners in higher insurance premiums.

In an Aurora subdivision, workers from Roselle-based Blue Rose Restoration were knocking on doors offering to conduct storm damage inspections.

That’s when one neighbor, off-duty news photographer Tim Horstman, caught a worker on-camera actually making dents into the siding of a home. The worker was caught jamming his thumb and fist repeatedly into aluminum siding.

“I thought to myself, did he just do what I think he did?” said Horstman.

Horstman saw, and videotaped, Chris Skedd of Blue Rose Restoration, damaging siding and even gutters. He was caught on tape using his body weight and thumb to make dents.

“I have nothing to say here,” said Skedd.

When asked why his thumb would make a dent, Skedd said, “That’s a good question.”

The house that was damaged belongs to Robert Perez. He says Skedd offered to inspect his home and was supposed to wait until after an insurance company adjuster inspection the following day.

Perez said Skedd instead came early and while he was away at work, which angers Perez.

Chris Skedd has been in trouble before. He has been arrested 11 times for theft, drugs, weapons, and even a DUI.

Skedd told CBS 2 that he gets commission for every house he signs up, but not until he finds enough damage to get the homeowners insurance to pay.

“I’d say you got some pretty good video,” said Roger Morris from the National Insurance Crime Bureau.

He says this type of alleged fraud has exploded in the last five years, costing everyone in higher premiums.

“It’s very serious and it’s fraud,” said Morris, who added that Illinois is the number one state in the nation for suspicious hail damage complaints.

The best way to avoid becoming a victim is to make sure your insurance company adjuster takes a look at any storm damage first.

Attempts to reach Blue Rose Restoration were unsuccessful.

Join Dave Savini’s Fan Page on Facebook.

View Comments
  • Bill A

    It is about time these storm chasers are being exposed. They may not all cause damage like this Guy. They are telling homeowners to file claims when most of the homeowners do not even have hail damage. All this does is upsets the homeowner. The stormchasers are running out of homes that had real damage and are now going into areas that were not effected. Then you have adjusters with no experience that pay for claims that have no damage.

  • Frank

    Its sad that one door to door company in which most adjusters know they are criminals can make so many other innocent compaies look bad. I am a adjuster and believe me if someone is knocking on your door its ok just check the bbb and ask for references, Not all door to door restoration companies are bad

  • Chris

    it’s about time these out of state storm chasers are exposed, as to the fruad they commet on homeowners. But the most fraud committed to homeowners in Illinois is by the insurance carriers. They have poorly trained adjusters, every company has different repair guidelines, so one insurance company will say yes you have true damage while another carrier says no.
    The state needs to punish the local roofing contractors who allow out ot stste roofers to use their licence but they also need to punish the carriers as well for the fraud they commit on homeowners–under their so called repair guidelines.
    homeowners in doubt use local roofing contractors who are licensed and HAAG certified..

    • josh

      Poorly trained adjusters and varying guild lines for what constitutes hail impact damage to roofing shingles and roof replacement certainly can be an issue in the industry. However, it is clearly not fraud. Fraud on the carrier’s side would constitute deliberate/intentional deception of the policy holder.

      A catastrophic hail event typically brings in tens of thousands of claims which usually can not be handled efficiently by an Insurance Carrier with a large exposure to the affected geographic area. The Insurance Carrier’s trained staff CAT Team simple can not keep up with the influx of claims and independent adjusters/adjusting companies must be brought in. Independent adjusters are paid on a fee base per claim which increases with the size of the claim. Due to this fact the typical independent adjuster will error on the side of the insured, which can be a problem for everyone. Carriers need to be carful who they choose to represent them for this reason among others which I don’t have the time to discuss now.

      I do agree a licensed local contractor who is Haag certified is a great start to finding a good construction company for storm repairs. It would be nice if everyone kept to the Haag standards for hail impact damage. The Haag standards are no brainers.

  • Red

    Adjusters are not lawyers or used car salesmen. Insurance policies are not maintnence plans. It takes hailstones larger than 1″ to damage shingles. That kind of hail is rare, but not always damaging. Your home is made to withstand weather. Why would pea-size hail be so catastrophic that you would allow a stranger, most times without a license, to access your roof and make you file a claim? Want to kno why your premiums go up and you never filed a claim in 30 years? Because moron ‘contractors’ either create damage or make you file a claim for damage that is minimal or not there. Then they pit the homeowner against the insurance company. If you have legitimate damage, and it is affecting your home, file a claim FIRST if you must, then let the insurance company do their inspection. If the damage is covered they will provide credible contractors to repair the affected areas. ‘Local’ doesn’t always mean good. American Dream is local to the Joliet-area and they advertise on the radio and The Weather Channel. They are STORM-CHASERS!!!!! They are NOT roofers. They sub out the roofing work if approved, which is why people think they are good. The person at your door following a storm is NOT a roofer, but a mere salesman. They can create damage and wreak havoc on you as they try to inflate damages. They have also been known to prey on female adjusters!!!! They will always ask what insurance company you have first, then once they get the adjusters info. If they do not like the adjusters because that adjuster knows what real damage is, they will leave you high and dry!!!!!

    • chris

      Being in the roofing business for a local company, I have reported several company’s to the state for the above, not one reply came back,
      If the carriers had proper trianed adjusters and fair area repair guidelines, most of these problems would not exist.. if you think it is wise to trust a carrier who is out to LIMIT their liability in these times,,,just look at all who trusted their carriers down in Ms. or La. The average homeowner from the april 4-5 storms had no knowledge they had storm damage until a door knocker informed them…some carriers give the homeowners a very short time to file a claim..yes i agree many homeowners think their policy is a maintance program,,,but then again the carriers think homeowners are just dumb,.,,,,

      • Peter

        Well, you aren’t a good roofer then. The storm was April 5-6, NOT April 4-5.

      • DD

        It doesn’t matter what insurance company you have, it comes down to whether or not the adjuster that arrives at your house is actually trained well in hail or not. Some of the larger companies in IL have hired independent adjusters that are paid based on the damages they find. The insurance companies aren’t out to deny a person’s claim like everyone thinks. Any adjuster will tell you that they’d like nothing better than to just pay a claim and never have to see or hear from it again. That sounds a little cold and calloused, but it’s the truth. People don’t like telling someone no as much as they don’t like hearing it. Most adjusters are college educated professionals and are out to help a homeowner and look to find coverage, not the other way around. The problem is that the state of Illinois has so many hail chasing contractors out to stir up a frenzy over damages that are minimal or nonexistent.

  • Chris

    sorry Peter for the typo error, I forgot how tempered All state adjusters-claim reps. are

  • Mrs. Schroeder

    I think it is completely ridiculous that “Chris” claims that being able to properly identify damages is not properly trained and again just proves why you do not want one of these storm chasers to inspect your property. Insurance companies do not send out just any person they can get to work for them out to adjust claims as these businesses do. Adjusters must have a college degree and go through training on a monthly basis to stay atop of the industry repair methods. I would like to know what kid of traingn you as a storm chaser go through since you are the first to throw out the term poorly trainied. Wouldn’t that be the pot calling the kettle black. Your trainng consists of memorizing a sales script about “catastrophic” damages and waiving a deductible to lock these homeowners in. Then when you realize there isn’t enough damage you “enhance” it. Obvoiusly storm chasers such as yourself can not bank off a home that is not damaged and if this isn’t truthful, please explain how entire neighborhoods where there was no hail storm are getting a new roof and siding…..

  • Chris

    Mrs. Schroeder wrote please explain how entire neighborhoods where there was no hail storm are getting a new roof and siding…..I guess you didn’t read the comments, poorly trained adjusters. then again you use the word you..if you only knew how many poorly trained adjusters i asked not to approve non storm damage you will use the word “them”. ask yourself this question, would you rather have a adjuster who never worked on roofs or siding handle your claim? or an honorable certified Haag contractor work with your adjuster? many adjusters who become seasoned over time and gain experience are sent packing by some carriers as they cover the loss completely..I am not a fan of bad carriers and poorly trained adjusters nor am I a fan of so called window and siding company’s that now advertise as insurance experts,,,i

    • DD

      I agree with a portion of this, as a supervisor for a large carrier you will always run into different levels of expertise both on the contractor and the adjuster’s experiences. As much as I would love to say otherwise not every adjuster is created equal, most are very good and very professional. You will run into the dd one that is newer, not as well trained, or can be bullied about by some contractors. If you heard the things that these chasers say either over the phone or while we are on a roof with them you would be appalled. They will be a person’s best friend in front of a homeowner, but the minute they are away from that person (and sometimes even in front of) it is a completely different person than before. Belittlement, intimidation, and sometimes mass numbers are used to get someone to pay for something. I’ve been on more than one roof this year with contractors who couldn’t even tell me what a shingle was composed of.

      i will agree that most contractors with Haag certifications are good, however keep in mind that this is not the end all be all for a good company/contractor. Just because someone can read and pass a test doesn’t always mean they have your best interest at heart. Most people who come from other states with a Haag certification use that only as a selling point. For people unaware Haag is pretty much the industry standard in regards to hail damage. they have high powered “guns” that will emulate a hail impact on different roofing materials and will show what the damage is from that type of impact.

      • PJK

        I was a student in the second Haag certification class given by that engineering firm. The class took five days and had a six hour exam at the end. Now, Haag will come to a storm chaser’s office and run their whole sales staff through the “certification” in a couple of days. It is quite clear that their standards have changed in terms of how the instruct. In the early days, they were fairly credible, but then they found that the real money in certification is to be found in training roof salesmen.

    • Chris

      I’ve worked as an adjuster in Illinois for many years. 80% of the claims are BS as well as 80% of the contractors I meet with are clueless. Not sure who you work for, but the large majority of all claims I inspect are ridiculous in the fact that our company has to spend time and resources to meet with “Restoration Companies” and “Insurance Experts” on the sides of vehicles. Absolute Joke.

  • Chris

    Mrs. Schroeder, now can you tell me how a home gets new siding all around when the hail storm only came from one side? HINT its not the insurance carrier guideleines as Illinois is not a matching state, must be those highly trained college adjusters you mentioned doing their job >>> improperly

  • Edward

    @Chris – Can you honestly say that as a someone who works on commission that you “asked not to approve non storm damage?”

    @cechini – “I don’t think it’s wrong to damage 2 sides of siding if the other sides are damaged.” Dumbest thing I’ve ever heard.

    • Chris

      Ed good business brings good business, adjusters know who are honest contractors and even though their not supposed to, you do get referals.and if there is a questionable issue you may be given the benefet of the doubt, intergerty should be a company’s highest priority.. granule loss may oocur long after one year as shingles also get brused from the hail, thus if you don’t file a claim within the carriers timeline you can’t claim the damage..

  • Edward

    @Chris – Explain very short time to file a claim? One year is a short time to inspect your home after a storm?

  • Jennifer S

    I want to thank CBS, and especially this photographer, for bringing to light a very important issue to homeowners in the Chicagoland area. As a local contractor, we unfortunately hear stories like this frequently from homeowners who come to us after bad experiences with storm chasers. If you’d like more information about how to avoid storm chasers, and the proper steps to take if you think that you may have hail damage, please feel free to visit http://www.BewareStormChasers.com. We developed the site after last April’s storm as a way of helping homeowners in the area make decisions about possible storm damage. It also includes information about other dishonest tactics that companies like this may use, and links to the IL Attorney General’s warnings about storm chasers.

    • frank

      jennifer your company is no better as we see you took this as a opportunity to advertise your company. by the way you use iko shingles which every roofer knows that is a garbage product, including you just trying to make more profit using a cheap shingle.

  • Gerald

    I am an adjuster working the April 5th hail storm. The carrier for whom I work DOES pay for the undamaged siding, assuming a match cannot be found. BUT, the homeowner has to either incur the cost, or at least present a contract indicating they will incur the cost, to replace the undamaged siding.
    -
    And yes, there is one YEAR to file a claim following the date of the storm. That isn’t a short time. I find it amazing that people are STILL filing claims from the April 5th hail storm, and then are SHOCKED when their claim is denied…never bothering to think that if they had damage, it wouldn’t have taken them 7 months to notice.
    -
    As for the contractors, this entire event is a contractor driven event. The carrier for whom I work has handled over 50,000 claims in homeowner’s alone. We should’ve been out of here and done with this storm in June or July. Anywhere else in the country, and we would have been. But here, thanks to contractors taking advantage of the situation, we’ll be here thru the winter and into next year. In Oklahoma, there wouldn’t have been a single claim filed for this hail. The hail did do damage in some areas, particularly Park Ridge/Niles/Des Plaines. But the damage is not critical, and most other areas in the country wouldn’t have even filed claims. (If you had aluminum siding damaged, this does not apply…I would’ve filed that claim too due to appearence)
    -
    Point is, these stormchasers are now starting to file out of here, heading to Arizona…where they will probably still be when your new roof starts leaking, and you’re trying to get in touch with them to fix it for you. HIRE LOCAL CONTRACTORS AND USE YOUR HEAD, POLICYHOLDER! If your fence blew down and you have a $1,000 deductible, DON’T FILE A CLAIM! I’ve written quite a few $100 checks lately for just that, based on the October 26-27 windstorm. Is it really worth it to file a claim to get $100 for the 30 feet of fence you lost? THINK!!

    • Lola

      you said “USE YOUR HEAD, POLICYHOLDER! If your fence blew down and you have a $1,000 deductible, DON’T FILE A CLAIM! I’ve written quite a few $100 checks lately for just that, based on the October 26-27 windstorm. Is it really worth it to file a claim to get $100 for the 30 feet of fence you lost? THINK!!”

      I totally agree with you, but I think when those claims come through that some of that responsability should be on the agents office. I work for an insurance agent and my one big responsablity is claims. Before i let anyone file a claim I tell them to think about it and think about their deductible and see if its worth it. I know a lot of agents dont do that, and that is not right either. Sometimes us as agents, we have to paint the insured a picture for them to understand their policy and deductible.

  • Gerald

    I want to add that there ARE some legitimate contractors out there. I understand that it is difficult, as most homeowner’s don’t know what hail damage looks like. I also understand there are “cheap” carriers out there that try to pay as little as possible.
    -
    With that said, the bottom line is this. Never have I worked where I met a contractor on nearly every claim. Literally 95% of them. It’s silly. The contractor does NOT “represent” the homeowner. The contractor represents his company. His concern is not you getting a new roof. His concern is you paying him for putting a new roof on your house. There’s nothing wrong with that, but think about it…his interest isn’t your well being…it’s HIS well being. If the contractor wanted to be helpful to the whole process, he would have his own estimate already drawwn up…PRICE INCLUDED…as though it isn’t an insurance claim. So far, I personally have handled over 500 claims. I have encountered 4…yes…4 contractors that had an estimate prepared before I got there. And by the way, an estimate isn’t “Per Insurance Proceeds”. Like I said, treat it like it’s a JOB…not an insurance claim. If the estimate was already prepared, and was in line with insurance proceeds, the carrier wouldn’t hold any depreciation! We could just tell the homeowner the estimate is in line, and it’s OK to sign a contract. This would ensure FULL payment up front, less deductible, AND…think about this, contractors…it would then assure you get the job…and you won’t have to wait for the second check.
    -
    Homeowners, think about that. Why would you EVER sign something without knowing if your claim was even going to be covered?? Ask them to give you an estimate, since they all claim to give free estimates. An estimate should include what the scope of work is, and how much it costs. It would if it wasn’t an insurance claim, and it should be no different. Contractors play no role….NO role…in the insurance claims process. Insurance adjusters are trained in hail damage identification, wind damage identification, AND…the policy, which is the CONTRACT you have with your insurance carrier. In other words, we know what is covered and what is not. A squirrel eating thru your roof and causing damage is not covered, no matter how much the contractor wants it to be. Your old worn out organic shingles are not covered, unless damaged by wind/hail, no matter how much the contractor wants them to be. There presence at the inspection does not change the policy, and SHOULDN’T change the process at all. It doesn’t with me.
    -
    We are taught as adjusters to look for a way to provide coverage. “If there’s a grey area, err on the side of the policyholder”. I’ve been taught that for YEARS…and that is the criteria I hold myself to as an adjuster. And yes…I am an independent adjuster, which means I actually get paid MORE if I pay more. That said, we still have to operate within the confines of the policy, which again, is the CONTRACT you have with your carrier.

  • FR

    Dishonest people and businesses like this should pay a VERY BIG FINE to help balance the state’s bugdet.

  • Chuck

    Gerald….you hit the nail on the head. I, too, have handled thousands of claims. Want to know a good contractor? CBA Construction. Precision Roofing and Siding is the best group I have ever encountered.

    An by the way, your turtle vents with those tiny dents? NOT damaged!!! Carriers are forced to pay for them but they are likely not affecting the ventilation of your home. So when you get a check for $100 after your deductible, don’t complain to your carrier!! Those vents have the same consistency as pop cans, and they barely show dents. So why would that same hailstone daage your roof? And explain to me how that hailstone didn’t tear your window screens? Common sense people!!!

    • william

      Nice of you to take advantage of the situation and plug Precision Roofing & Siding (Farmers lap dog that will agree with Farmers on any claim to stay one of their preferred contractors).

      I know for a fact that Precision knocks on doors for storm damage in the areas being called “minor damage”. They came to my door offering a free inspection in Elgin. Significant hail never came CLOSE to Elgin on the April storm.

      Do your homework before throwing companies under the bus and plugging for your buddies.

  • Japoose

    Gerald you couldn’t be more right. Chris you must take everyone for fools if you think that for one second we are going to believe that you insist that adjusters not pay for undamaged siding. In fact all you storm chasers do is complain about how you can’t repair this or can’t fix that, “looks like we need to tear off the whole roof” for a few missing shingles, and throw in all new siding while we are at it. They day your company can acutally make a repair without crying about how you have to tear the whole roof off, then MAYBE you can call yourself a roofer because all you are is a glorified salesman. Why don’t you get a real job instead of making a living scamming insurance companies and homeowners out of money, probably can’t because you don’t have one of those college educations you frowned upon.

    • Agent

      Great comment!!!!
      Thats all the roofers cry about, then they go and tell the homeowner that it is us (insurance companies) that dont want to pay. But its scammers like them that make the rates go through the ROOF!

  • ELLIE

    This is a very big issue that affects many people, I as an insurance agent find it very difficult to tell our clients premium went up due to a claim for which nothing was paid out. It’s even more frustraiting that these roofing companies are badgering our customers to file claims even though there is no damage.
    American Dream Home Improvement is another scamming company, one we have been hearing from a Lot, Homeowner’s beware!

  • frank

    @chris – If you are HAAG certified then you know that HAAG says the damage is immediate – as well since I am sure you are an insurance “claims” specialist you also know that just about every policy in the nation regardless of carrier covers “sudden and accidental direct physical loss.” The argument that granules are lost up to a year later point is invalid. As well if you were familiar with HAAG you would also know that they state that granular loss occurs every time YOU get on a roof as well as every time it rains, and is not considered to be functional damage. As far as you complaining about inexperienced adjusters, well when adjusters allow for i.e. buy stuff, that they are not supposed to buy, its not driven by ignorance, but rather greed. I’m sure you know that there are some independent contractor adjusters who get paid based on the amount of damage they allow for not for what they don’t allow for, and yes it does make it tough to work in the same neighborhoods and to have to explain to insured’s why there roof isn’t getting bought because their neighbors roof is getting bought, and explaining to them why a salesperson is telling them that they need a new roof and that they have “got other roofs bought” in the same neighborhood. I know that the intelligent insured’s will recognize salespeople attempting to undermine our process. At the end of the day what you forget is this – as insurance carriers’ and adjusters, we are held responsible by the department of insurance in every single state ( run by the government ) and could be held liable in a court of law for every minute detail we report on. Salespeople might, and I emphasize might be held responsible by the BBB and that’s about it. Accountability it’s the law over here.

    • creager

      Well Frank, I ‘m not trying to argue with you whatsoever, you make some valid points. I am and have been HAAG “certified” for 4yrs for whatever that’s worth. Damage is damage and if its real and present this type of “prepping” doesnt occur or ever need to. there are many quality local storm contractors who come not only reccomended by the BBB, but come with local references and company history as well. DO YOUR RESEARCH before you select a contractor.

      To imply that all adjustors do the right thing or act in the best intrest of the policy holder is a misnomer of grand proportions.

    • CDP

      Thanks Frank, you just saved me a lot of typing. Having been through 2 HAAG seminars taught by Tim Marshall, Chris lost all credibility when me mentioned granule loss.

  • J.P.

    My question would be if you did do business with this company and our insurance paid out on it will there be any repercussions for me with my insurance company?? We were told our rates would not go up because it was an act of God. We checked them out on the BBB and they had a good rating. I guess I can’t penalize the company for the wrong doing of one employee.

    • Agent

      any kind of claim that your insurance pays out affects your premium. You are penalized no matted how big or small that claim is. I work for a Big name insurance company. If the insurance adjustor goes out and takes a look at the roof and truly sees wind and hail damage the insurance WILL pay. However roof claims in this area have gone up due to this “storm chasers”. Pretty much all the homeowner has to do is hire a well known contractor and make sure the contractor is licensed in your city!! Also DONT SIGN ANYTHING!!!! A lot of this contractors push homeowners to sign the contract, please becareful!!! If you sign a contract and your insurance denies the claim, YOU ARE STUCK getting the work done by that contractor because you signed the contract. BE SMART! do your homeowork, after all it is your house and you want to make sure they do good work!

  • Squidward

    As an adjuster with 15 years experience, I can tell you that these chasers have no knowledge of roofs whatsoever. If an adjuster speaks intelligently and doesn’t back down, these guys will back off immediately. These guys prey on young adjusters that have no experience or roof knowledge.

  • trom briggs

    those don’t even remotely look like hail damage.

  • Paul

    As an adjuster w/6 years experience, I have seen adjusters never leave their car from the Big 3 Insurance Companies. They pull up, hand the camera to the contractor, the contractor hands them a paper. The contractor walks away and comes back a few minutes later. The adjuster then goes and talks to the homeowners. The adjuster is done in ~20 minutes. This is not enough time to properly inspect roof and siding, write the estimate and review with the policy holder. I was raised to be leery of anyone that came to your door trying to peddle something. Insurance is not a maintenance policy. Roofing companies that will argue with you include American Dream (always get a $2000 supplement after work completed), Euclid, Expert Roofing. Their are local roofers out there that are decent. Homeowners, be aware of who you have represent you!!!!

  • Heather

    Chris is not a worker or employee of Blue Rose!
    He is an independent contractor! His actions are just that HIS ACTIONS!!!
    Because he chose to do illegal actions doesn’t mean that it is condoned or even accepted By Blue Rose in any way.

    • cechini

      I agree. I own a local storm business in McHenry county (formerly in Algonquin). The salesmen are subcontracted, not employees.

    • Sammy S

      Just Like you did not damage my House Heather. We have u! on Tape!!

  • Tony Yu

    Haha I know skedd!!! he would do something like taht

    • smokie

      hahahhahahaha

      • paul

        haha hell naw

  • Erik

    Blue Rose is not the only storm chaser creating damage. 123 caused damage to my house in Oswego.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Listen Live!

RSS Most Popular News

Follow CBS Chicago

Like us on foursquare

RSS Contests & Promotions

WBBM Newsradio 780, Radio Stations & Broadcast Companies, Chicago, IL

Twitter Updates