A Tree-Trimming Debate Grows In Brookfield

BROOKFIELD, Ill. (CBS) – There’s a controversy blossoming in the west suburban of Brookfield over the city’s trees.

As CBS 2’s Mike Puccinelli reports, critics say the village’s tree-trimming effort has gotten out of hand.

The $100,000 program aims to keep Brookfield’s designation as a Tree City USA town.

Resident Pete Mandra is among those unhappy with the local efforts, including the results on the tree in the front of his house.

“I think they’re butchering the trees,” says Mandra, who fears some trees could die.

His tree has been trimmed down to the trunk about 20 feet up. A block away, a far taller tree has been trimmed in much the same way.

“I feel they are over-trimming the trees,” says Robin O’Malley, the former president of the Brookfield Garden Club. “I think they are trimming small branches off that don’t need to be taken off.”

Village forester Scott DeRoss says the trees will actually come back stronger, and he says the limbs have to be removed in order to insure public safety.

“I’ve never had a tree die from trimming,” he says.

Critics say tiny limbs are being removed that couldn’t possibly pose a threat. O’Mally calls it “busy work.”

“Our contractors are not butchering the trees,” counters Alan Kitzer, Brookfield public works superintendent. “They’re doing what’s best for the public safety and the health of these trees.”

Officials say the village is liable if any resident or visitor is injured because of a falling tree limb. They add there is likely no way they can satisfy all of the village’s residents, because opinions about tree-trimming tend to vary so widely.

More from Mike Puccinelli
  • Roberta Waker

    The solution is simple – call in an arborist to check the trees, then you will know for certain if they have been damaged or overtrimmed. Proper trimming is good for the health of any tree, but trimming improperly can cause damage that could eventually kill the tree. Arborists don’t usually charge for an inspection or consultation, only for work they might have to do.

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live