Wisch: At Long Last, Illini Hire A True Head Coach

By Dave Wischnowsky –

(CBS) Twenty years ago, after compiling a sterling 30-16-1 record on the football field at that “basketball school” down in Champaign, University of Illinois coach John Mackovic bolted the Land of Lincoln for the gridiron riches of the Lone Star State.

And Fighting Illini football has never been the same.

In large part, that’s because the school hasn’t had a head football coach since then. Not really, at least. Certainly not a true one.

No, to replace Mackovic, who went on to experience a mixed bag at Texas, Illinois athletic director Ron Guenther turned to Illini defensive coordinator Lou Tepper. At Illinois, Tepper’s defenses were mighty, but his offensive outputs meek. So, after five years and a 25-31-2 record, he was mercifully fired.

To remedy Illinois’ lack of scoring, Guenther then turned to an offensive coordinator in Chicago Bears assistant coach Ron Turner. His Illini teams went on to score at a rapid rate, but the NFL-minded Turner had no appetite for the college recruiting game and the number of top athletes waned. So, after eight seasons and a 35-57 record, he was mercifully fired.

To fix Illinois’ dearth of talent, Guenther then turned to a “recruiter” in Ron Zook, the recently deposed head coach at Florida. Making an early splash, Zook did upgrade the Illini’s personnel, but just as quickly showed he had little ability to manage a program – or a game clock – and so, after seven seasons and a 34-50 record, he was mercifully fired.

All of that brings us up to today, when after two decades, three failed coaches and 138 frustrating losses (an average of nearly seven a season), the Fighting Illini have finally hired a guy in Toledo’s 46-year-old Tim Beckman who appears to be a legitimate head coach and not merely a nominal one such as the eternally befuddled Zook, or an out-of-place coordinator like both Tepper and Turner so clearly were.

CBS2’s Ryan Baker reported Thursday night that Beckman would be introduced Friday and The Toledo Blade reported this morning that Beckman told his players at a 7 a.m. team meeting that he had accepted the Illinois job.

Two weeks ago in this blog, I urged new Illinois athletic director Mike Thomas to first aim high in his coaching search by targeting the likes of Boise State’s Chris Petersen and Texas Christian’s Gary Patterson, and then adjust accordingly.

In Friday’s Chicago Tribune, columnist David Haugh wrote that Thomas apparently did just that as he reportedly pursued Petersen, as well as Cincinnati’s Butch Jones and the nation’s hotshot du jour, Houston’s Kevin Sumlin.

Wednesday afternoon, my Downstate sources informed me that Sumlin-to-Illinois was nearly a done deal and an announcement could be imminent. What happened later that evening, or how close that deal was to actual fruition, is unclear.

This, however, is quite clear: Beckman is very likely a better hire than Sumlin, and Illinois fans would be wise to give the guy a chance even if he lacks that national buzz. A smaller name doesn’t necessarily mean a lesser one.

This season, Sumlin indeed racked up major hype – and big point totals – as his Houston Cougars stormed their way to a 12-0 record and a lofty national ranking. But it’s important to note that those wins came against a lineup of schools that featured only two with winning records – Louisiana Tech and Tulsa (both 8-4) – and had a paltry 55-77 mark overall.

In the Conference USA championship game last weekend, Sumlin matched wits with Southern Mississippi’s Larry Fedora and was outclassed as Houston lost 49-28 to the 11-2 Golden Eagles, by far the best squad the Cougars faced all year.

Beyond this season, it’s disconcerting that Sumlin has won nothing without record-setting quarterback Case Keenum running his offense. With Keenum, Sumlin’s record is an eye-popping 32-10. But without him – Keenum tore his ACL in the third game of the 2010 season and missed the rest of the year – Sumlin is just 3-7.

Unlike former Texas Tech coach Mike Leach whose Red Raiders teams piled up prolific points with a series of different quarterbacks, Sumlin is also yet to prove that it’s his offensive genius – and not simply Keenum’s arm – that’s the reason behind Houston’s success.

I don’t at all think Sumlin is worth the $3 million that Illinois reportedly offered him this week, nor do I believe he’ll be worth whatever it is that Texas A&M or another BCS conference school may ultimately pay him this month. He simply hasn’t yet earned it.

Meanwhile, Beckman, who is 21-16 in three years at Toledo, is getting his shot in Champaign. And while I can hardly guarantee that he’ll be a success, Mike Thomas has plucked his past two coaches, Brian Kelly and Butch Jones, from the Mid-American Conference and both enjoyed big success at Cincinnati. And in Beckman, he picked another good one.

Last year, Beckman’s Rockets beat Purdue 31-20 and played Ohio State within 27-22 in September. For the second straight season, they’ve finished 7-1 in the MAC, with both losses coming to Northern Illinois, including a 63-60 decision this year.

For those Illini fans skeptical of hiring a coach from the MAC, I’d remind you that Woody Hayes (Miami), Ara Parseghian (Miami), Nick Saban (Toledo), Urban Meyer (Bowling Green) and Bo Schembechler (Miami) all began their careers in that conference, as well.

After seven years of watching Ron Zook mismanage play calls, clocks and extra-point opportunities, what I want to see on the sidelines in Champaign more than anything is a man with a realistic chance of outcoaching his opponent on any given Saturday.

Additionally, after 20 years of having head coaches suited for success in just one aspect of a multi-faceted game, I also want a guy who can run an entire football program.

You know, a real head coach.

Based on his background, Beckman looks as if he could be that man, although figuring out a way to keep Illini defensive coordinator Vic Koenning in the fold would certainly help. Beckman also has an apparent passion – and flair – for recruiting, which also bodes well.

“I think that job [Illinois] is the right job,” Dick Strahm, who coached Beckman at the University of Findlay (Ohio), told the Champaign News-Gazette on Thursday. “He will recruit at Illinois. There is no question about it. I don’t know how many of his staff he’s bringing along with him but I know they were outrecruiting everybody in the Mid-American.”

Beckman has been doing his fair share of outcoaching them, as well.

And if he can bring all of those abilities with him to Memorial Stadium, Beckman could be the head coach that gets Illinois football headed in the right direction.


  • tom Sharp

    Hey Dave, do you and Beckman know that defense isn’t optional in the Big Ten!?

  • Dave Wischnowsky

    Pretty sure that’s why I wrote it would help to find a way to keep current defensive coordinator/interim head coach Vic Koenning, Tom.

    • Mike Cannon


  • Mike Cannon

    Good take on what I think is a solid hire. I firmly believe in hiring for future potential and not just based on what you’ve done. Beckman turned around what was a moribund program at UT into a perennial contender. If he can do the same here he’ll be a god.

    Go Illini!

  • Markie Maypo

    I still don’t understand how you look at a 21-16 record at TOLEDO and have all this confidence. Yes, at least he has BEEN a head coach…but so had Zook….at freaking FLORIDA. He won 8 games this season…7 of which came against the MAC!!!! Ohio State, Boise State, Syracuse, Northern Illinois are the ONLY decent programs they played…they lost EVERY ONE of those games. I’m willing to give the guy a chance to coach the talent that Illinois has. Maybe he’ll be fine. But let’s not act like he’s in the same league with Chris Petersen or Gary Patterson, who took sub-level programs and made them NATIONALLY relevant. He’s a guy right now. That’s all.

    • J-Dubya

      A good friend of mine has a nephew that has a lot of potential. Sr. in high school. He is going to a MAC school. They offered him a full ride. A Big 10 school wouldn’t even look at him.

      The fact is that Ohio State, Boise State, and Syracuse get better talent than Toledo. So does Illinois. I also think that Toledo’s loss to OSU was closer than UofI’s.

      I agree completely with Dave. They need someone with Head Coaching experience that knows how to put points on the board. If they can keep Koenning or get another top notch d-coordinator they have a fighting chance. I like that model over hiring a good coordinator and giving him his first chance as a HC.

      I was really afraid that they would hire Mike Martz. It would have been poetic since Turner went from the Bears to the Illini and back to the Bears. That guy was in my life for a decade or more.

    • Dave Wischnowsky

      I don’t think I said he’s anything other than that, Markie. But Beckman is a guy that deserves a fair shot from Illini fans. There’s absolutely no reason why not. And nowhere did I say that he’s Petersen or Patterson. I said Illinois AD Mike Thomas should aim high (which he apparently did by targeting Petersen) and then adjust accordingly (which he did by hiring Beckman).
      I think it’s key to also be aware of this: At Houston, Kevin Sumlin inherited good program – and a great quarterback – from Art Briles and went 23-16 in his first three seasons. Beckman inherited mess at Toledo and went 21-16 first three seasons.

      • Markie Maypo

        I guess that’s true. Toledo was a mess to fix. I’d still like to see a larger sample size from “prospective coaches”. However, as an Illinois fan, it’s sometimes hard for me to admit that it’s simply NOT a “top flight job” these days. Illinois is a middle of the pack program, bordering on bottom of the pile. I am definitely willing to give this guy a shot. It just seemed like there was more optimism about him than I though was warranted.

        P.S. I wouldn’t have wanted the guy from Houston anyway lol

  • Larry Horse's Arse

    I think it was a great hire…he has the potential to be a Barry Alverez as per one of Dave’s recent columns.

    • Dave Wischnowsky

      Exactly, Arse. That’s the hope. It’s a possibility.

  • Gary Evans

    You forgot, Lou Holtz also came from the MAC, the “Cradle of Coaches”.

  • illini Forever

    We are a mid-major.

  • IlliniFan3

    Looking forward to see what he can do!

  • Lou Liay

    Dave…excellent column…right on…I was outof town and first voice mail on my phone was recorded Tim Beciman saying how glad he is to be at Illinois.
    Hey Baby…we are going to win…this guy can do it…I have great faith in Mike Thomas and his ability to hire. Go Illini…Buy Tickets

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live