Violin Shop Owner Sues Over Mysterious Defamatory Critic

CHICAGO (CBS) — The owner of a Chicago violin shop is suing the unidentified writer of what he says are defamatory Internet postings.

As WBBM Newsradio’s Mike Krauser reports, an attorney for the shop owner says the message all came from the same IP address.

LISTEN: WBBM Newsradio’s Mike Krauser reports

The writer posted on Yelp that Chunyee Lu, owner of the Guadagnini Violin shop at 407 S. Dearborn St., was a “ripoff artist.”

The lawsuit filed Tuesday in Cook County Circuit Court identifies the defendant only by the online monikers used on various review sites: TRUTHETELLER1790, TRUTH TELLER and TRUTH T. But the common IP address suggests they’re all the same person, Lu’s attorney, James Branit, alleges.

The comments were posted last January on Yelp, as well as,, and

The writer, under the name “TruthT.,” posted on Yelp: “Would you like to buy a gold mounted tortoise shell bow for $4500 that is actually worth $800 and is, in fact, made of gold-colored metal and faux-plastic shell? Then please go to this shop!”

Under another moniker, “Truthteller1790” posted a comment titled “RIPOFF ARTIST.” In the post, the critic states: “Please don’t go to this shop unless you want to be sold something which isn’t what its (SIC) purported to be for an outrageous price. They also will try to convince you your instrument needs a super expensive repair when it (SIC) just need an adjustment. Ripoff.”

Branit says the comments are false and misleading and the writer should be held accountable.

“One concern is that something like this can be done by a competitor of ours or, by somebody who is seeking to harm us for whatever personal reason they have,” Branit told the Chicago Sun-Times, adding: “Society has to balance the injury that’s being done by these anonymous reviews with the interest society has in allowing people to write these sorts of things anonymously.”

Lu has filed a separate legal action to unmask the writer’s identity. Last year, they went to court and asked RCN — which sells bundled cable, phone and internet service — to track the identity of the owner through the IP address, Branit said. That case is still pending.

Guadagnini’s has been in business for 25 years. In the suit, Lu boasts of decades of experience in restoring fine instruments and bows, and counts some of the most influential musicians around the world as clients.

The suit is seeking in excess of $50,000 in damages.

The Chicago Sun-Times contributed to this report, via the Sun-Times Media Wire.

  • Roberta Waker

    If the poster was ripped off as he says, he didn’t post lies and therefore the lawsuit should be dismissed. I know businesses with AAA+ Better Business Bureau ratings that are rip offs. Reviews, as long as they are not defamatory slander, or outright lies are a person’s opinion and their IP address should NOT be made public.

  • John Hansen

    This is a new and uncharted area of the civil law. I look forward to seeing it resolved.

  • Chicago Medical Malpractice Attorney says Recent 'Alert' Should Wake Medical … | Lawyer Adviser

    […] Sun-Times, adding: “Society has to balance the injury that's being … Read more on CBS Local […]

  • Dane Kantner

    “TRUTHETELLER1790, TRUTH TELLER and TRUTH T. But the common IP address suggests they’re all the same person, ”

    are you imploying that “Truth T” is an IP address? it’s not. please look up what an IP address is…. or did the attorney subpoena for Yelp’s traffic logs and actually obtain his IP addresses? If so, that in it of itself would be an amazing accomplishment, possibly a privacy issue for users, and worth noting in your article. if that’s not the implication here, the statement is poorly written at best

  • Larry Horse's Arse Horse's Arse

    Learn to read, Dane. They’ve taken separate action to uncover the IP addresses of those three monikers.

    If these types of suits are successful, sites like Yelp will get half the reviews they currently get. Yelp is full of fake reviews in both directions (positive, negative).

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live