Hearing Set For Man Convicted Of Killing Family, Cutting Baby From Womb

CHICAGO (CBS) — One of the people convicted of the murder of a pregnant woman and cutting out her unborn child over 15 years ago is headed back to court next week.

As WBBM Newsradio’s Nancy Harty reports, U.S. District Judge Matthew Kennelly has said Fedell Caffey will get a chance to argue why he feels he did not get a fair trial before he was convicted of the 1995 murder of Debra Evans and two of her children in their Addison apartment.

LISTEN: WBBM Newsradio’s Nancy Harty reports

Chicago-Kent Law School Professor Richard Kling handled some of Caffey’s previous unsuccessful appeals.

“Now, the ball is in the other court, and Judge Kennelly has said Mr. Caffey is going to be allowed to prove what he says existed,” Kling said.

Kling says those allegations include that a DuPage County prosecutor on the case was buying drugs from a witness, and some defense witnesses were not allowed to testify.

“We tracked down those witnesses, and we have tape recorded statements of a lot of those witnesses. We have some sworn affidavits and depositions of those witnesses,” Kling said.

Caffey, now 39, was convicted and sentenced to death in Evans’ murder. His girlfriend, Jacqueline Williams, and Williams’ cousin, Levern Ward, were also convicted for their roles in the murders.

Caffey’s death sentence was commuted to life in prison when then-Gov. George Ryan cleared Death Row in 2003.

Caffey and Ward killed Debra Evans, her 10-year-old daughter, Samantha, and her 7-year-old son, Joshua. Afterward, they cut Evans’ full-term fetus from her womb. The baby, named Elijah, survived.

Immediately following the murders, Caffey’s cousins claimed he wasn’t even there, and that Williams planned and carried out the murders on her own. Caffey’s family said Williams had told him was pregnant, and needed to produce a baby so he wouldn’t leave, CBS 2 reported in 1995.

That baby was allegedly the one cut from Debra Evans.

Caffey has continued to maintain he is innocent, and Kling says there was no physical evidence linking him to the gruesome crime.

Both sides are due before Judge Kennelly on Feb. 15, when he is expected to set the schedule for the evidentiary hearing.

Kling predicts it will be months before the hearing begins, because Caffey needs to get attorneys appointed and go over evidence from a case that is over 10 years old.

  • CFLC

    Only in the State of Illinois!

    • NWA

      Especially in the state of Illinois where they always get it wrong.


  • Nick Chicago

    Lawyers are ass—-s,it this crime happened to his family would his still be so concerned?

  • g-man

    Why is this turd still alive !!!!!!!!!!!

  • tony

    bottom feeding lawyers love cases like this .they charge the taxpapers millions .he did it and he should have been dead years ago.loevy and loevy law firm makes millions off the taxpayers of chicago .

  • This is all Ryan's fault

    The family has to suffer over and over hearing the gruesome details and the taxpayers have to keep paying for all the appeals and court time.
    Thanks to the the crooked Ryan.
    Would he have pardoned all these death row people had his granchildren been slaughtered?

  • Lyndia

    I hate to say this, but I must tell the truth. I remember this case well. I felt so sorry for the mother and her two children. It was wrong, wrong, wrong. I believed he knew what they were going to do even if he was not there. When they arrested him, he said he said he was being framed but I never believed him. If he gets free, this will be the second time that a person was released from jail that I personnally believe is guilty.

  • Just the Average Joe

    I don’t know if he is guilty or not, but where was the evidence? Was it testimony of a witness? I can’t see convicting someone for murder and giving them life, or death, without clear and convincing evidence. If he did it, cut off his head.

  • jb

    hopefully the truth will come out. fedell is innocent!!!

  • Just Axin

    I remember this case well, too. These a-holes killed the white mother, white daughter and white son and did not kill the black/mixed young child and let the black/mixed newborn live. See what happens when you get in a relationship with a brotha.

  • The real James Hamilton

    Prayers for the children and family we love you guys.

  • http://chicago.cbslocal.com/2012/02/15/new-trial-for-man-convicted-of-killing-family-cutting-baby-from-womb/ New Trial For Man Convicted Of Killing Family, Cutting Baby From Womb? « CBS Chicago

    […] Caffey, now 39, was convicted and sentenced to death in Evans’ murder. His girlfriend, Jacqueline … […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live