St. Valentine’s Day Massacre To Be Commemorated With Annual Reenactment

CHICAGO (CBS) — Valentine’s Day might be all about heart-shaped boxes and red roses to some, but in Chicago, it’s not complete until a Tommy gun is fired.

This is the 83rd anniversary of the infamous St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, and as always, Tommy Gun’s Garage, at 2114 S. Wabash Ave. in the South Loop, is holding a reenactment.

Beginning at 6 p.m., guests will be treated to dinner and a show for $65 – with hooch available for extra – as they reenact the brutal incident, along with an audience-interactive roaring 20s musical comedy dinner show.

“We don’t advertise this as a romantic evening, because it isn’t,” Tommy Gun’s Garage says on its notice. “So if youse want romance, Tommy Says, “Go somewhere else!”

In a posting Tuesday with some alternative ideas for celebrating Valentine’s Day, Andrea at the Chicago Quirk blog says the reenactment is not for the faint of heart.

“I can promise you, the re-enactment is extremely realistic, so if you scare easily I would skip it,” she says.

As Troy Taylor’s historical essay “Blood, Roses and Valentines” recalls, the events that led up to the massacre started in 1924 with murder of gang leader Dion O’Banion, who was the chief competition to Chicago Outfit leader Johnny Torrio in the bootleg liquor business. O’Banion controlled the North Side operation, Torrio the South Side.

After a brewery acquisition deal between the two men went bad, Torrio ordered a hit on O’Banion. The North Side gang vowed revenge, and a five-year war between the two gangs began.

Torrio himself was later shot and seriously wounded. While he would survive his wounds and live to the age of 75, he decided to give up control of the Outfit to Al Capone.

Capone’s gang went on to take out Hymie Weiss, leaving the North Side bootlegging operation in the hands of George “Bugs” Moran, a bitter enemy of Capone’s whom he wanted nothing more than to take out, Taylor recounted.

Early in 1929, Moran and a henchman killed Pasquillano Lolordo, a Capone associate, and Capone decided to have Moran done away with once and for all, Taylor recounted.

Capone arranged to have someone contact Moran and tell him a special shipment of bootleg whiskey would be shipped to a garage Moran owned at 2122 N. Clark St. When a group of Moran’s associates arrived at the garage, four Capone associates stormed in, posing as police officers conducting a raid.

They lined up six members of Moran’s gang and a seventh unaffiliated man against a wall, took out machine guns from their overcoats, and opened fire, according to the Encyclopedia of Chicago.

But Moran himself was not present, and thus survived. And Capone was in Florida at the time, and law enforcement could never link him to the crime, the encyclopedia said. No one was ever tried in the killings.

The garage where the massacre happened, which was marked “SMC Cartage Company,” was demolished in 1967, the encyclopedia said.

A side yard for the Margaret Day Blake apartments, a Chicago Housing Authority seniors’ development, now occupies the land.

Meanwhile, the brick wall against which the victims of the massacre were lined up was put to a bizarre use after the demolition.

As points out, Canadian businessman George Patey bought all the bricks at auction and reassembled them in the men’s room of his Banjo Palace nightclub in Vancouver, B.C. With the addition of a Plexiglas screen, the reassembled bricks became a urinal wall, with conveniently placed targets.

The Banjo Palace closed in 1976, and the wall was auctioned off again, one brick at a time, said.

Some of the bricks were reassembled the new Las Vegas Mob Museum, which just happens to be celebrating its grand opening this Valentine’s Day.

  • Centurion

    A re-enactment of multiple murders! Hey Tommy Guns, whats next…you want to re-enact the Gacy murders? How about re-enacting the murder of Jennifer Hudson’s family? Remember those kids who were murdered in Aurora…the baby cut from the womans womb….how about that….what a re-enactment that would be.

  • be mine

    re-enactment should be in englewood

  • Centurion

    I have an idea…how about lining up all the Chicago Alderman! Now if you put dose guys up against a wall..and then put the selector switch to full auto….you will have a BIG AUDIENCE

  • Malcom

    how stupid. how about re enacting digging up all those boys thatJohn Wayne Gacey killed next? This is outrageous.

  • Author: Capone Not Behind Valentine’s Day Massacre « CBS Chicago

    […] ending a decades-long practice that has cost the system tens of millions of dollars a year. 472St. Valentine’s Day Massacre To Be Commemorated With Annual ReenactmentValentine’s Day might be all about heart-shaped boxes and red roses to some, but in Chicago, […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Daily Weather Reports Delivered To You!SIGN UP NOW: Get daily weather reports every morning from meteorologist Steve Baskerville!
CBS Sports Radio RoundupGet your latest sports talk from across the country.

Listen Live